2026 Royals Season in Review: Tyler Tolbert

Tyler Tolbert 2026 Royals Season Review

In a column for Royals Review, analyst Shawn Coleman argues that Tyler Tolbert stands out as one of the more polarizing yet valuable players on the Kansas City Royals.

This past season tested Tolbert across seven different defensive positions while he managed a limited offensive workload. Drafted in the 13th round of the 2019 MLB Draft out of the University of Alabama-Birmingham, Tolbert was the only 13th round pick from that draft that played in the Majors last season.

Over 142 career games, Tolbert has accumulated a 0.6 WAR with 43 stolen bases while slashing .283/.340/.389 across 180 career at-bats.

During the past season, Tolbert appeared in seven different positions, missing time only at first base and catcher. He also made five relief appearances on the mound, pitching 4.2 innings while allowing 17 hits, 13 runs, four home runs, and three walks with no strikeouts.

Excluding his pitching appearances, Tolbert recorded a 0.7 WAR for the season, bringing his career total to 1.0 WAR. At the plate, he logged 130 at-bats with a .285/.347/.392 slash line, three home runs, 12 walks, and 22 stolen bases.

Tolbert also tied an MLB record by recording 12 straight at-bats with a hit, which included back-to-back five-hit games, matching a feat last accomplished by Roberto Clemente. Defensively, he committed three errors across seven positions, posting a -1 fielding run value and a +1 Outs Above Average on Baseball Savant.

Coleman contends that Tolbert deserves an extended opportunity to prove his worth given his production in limited action. The column evaluates the player as an above-average contributor when given regular chances on the field.