95-Year Cold Case: The Unsolved 1932 Bombing of Sacco-Vanzetti Judge Thayer’s Worcester Home


On a September night in 1932, a time bomb destroyed Judge Webster Thayer’s Worcester home — the third explosion in the city that week — and neighbors told The Evening Gazette they had been expecting it for years, telegram.com reported.

  • A bomb with 50 sticks of dynamite leveled 180 Institute Road on Sept. 28, 1932; Thayer, his wife and a maid survived with minor injuries.
  • The attack followed the 1927 executions of Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti, whom Thayer had convicted in a globally protested trial.
  • Massachusetts State Police called the device a time “infernal machine”; more than 600 sticks of stolen dynamite were never recovered.
  • The case remains unsolved nearly 95 years later despite a $25,000 state reward.

The Olympia Theater on Pleasant Street blew first.

Then Poli’s Palace, now the Hanover Theatre, on Southbridge Street. The third blast hit Institute Road, where Thayer lived. Police Capt. Robert T. Hardy described the act as “the work of a maniac,” The Evening Gazette reported at the time. Days later the paper called it “a roar that awoke the city.”

Trial that drew the world’s rage

Thayer, born in Blackstone and a graduate of Worcester Academy and Dartmouth College, presided over the 1921 Braintree murder trial of Sacco and Vanzetti. The two Italian immigrants followed Luigi Galleani, an anarchist known for political violence. A jury convicted both men in five hours on April 9, 1927. Sacco shouted, “You kill two innocent men,” as the verdict was read; Vanzetti stood silent. Both died in the electric chair in August 1927.

Protests and bombings erupted worldwide. In December 1927, the National City Bank of New York headquarters and the Bank of Boston in Buenos Aires were bombed. In 1928, attackers targeted a Buenos Aires train carrying President-elect Herbert Hoover, the New York City subway system and a Philadelphia church — all credited to Sacco and Vanzetti supporters, telegram.com reported.

Photo: aol.com

Thayer spoke of duty as police found stolen dynamite

Time magazine quoted Thayer after the Worcester bombing: “They can’t kill me that easily. I hate to think because a man does his duty by God and country, he gets this.” State police found the bomb was a timed device loaded with 50 sticks of dynamite. Around the same period, authorities discovered more than 600 sticks of dynamite stolen across Massachusetts, including about 84 pounds from Worcester. None was ever recovered.

Official scrutiny of the judge

Gov. Alvan T. Fuller appointed a committee to review the death sentences. The panel called Thayer’s conduct “a grave breach of official decorum” but upheld the verdict and denied clemency. In 1977, Gov. Michael Dukakis declared Aug. 23 Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti Memorial Day, saying the pair had been “unfairly tried and convicted” and that “any disgrace should be forever removed from their names.”

Cold case endures

The state offered a $25,000 reward for clues; no one claimed it. Thayer spent his remaining years in Boston under constant guard. In 1946 a modest ranch rose on the site, the address changed from 180 Institute Road to 2 Beechmont St. The bombing of his home remains unsolved.