Judge Dismisses Conspiracy Claim in Karen Read Lawsuit Against Canton but Allows Negligence Claim to Proceed

A judge dismissed the conspiracy claim in Karen Read’s lawsuit against the Town of Canton but let her negligence claim proceed, NBC Boston reported.

  • Plymouth Superior Court Judge Mark Gildea ruled Monday, November 16, 2026, that Read failed to allege an agreement between Canton and State Police to steer the investigation.
  • The negligence claim survives with a $100,000 damages cap under the Massachusetts Tort Claims Act.
  • Read settled with Massachusetts State Police earlier this month for $100,000.
  • A wrongful-death suit by John O’Keefe’s estate against Read remains pending.

Judge Gildea wrote that Read’s argument “confuses the very nature of a conspiracy,” finding no examples in state law “where a civil conspiracy claim was based on negligent conduct,” as her complaint outlined. The ruling, issued Monday, held that a civil conspiracy claim requires intentional acts and an agreement between the departments to direct the investigation toward Read, which her suit did not establish, MassLive reported.

Read’s lawyers had argued the departments’ carelessness, not a deliberate act, pointed the investigation at her.

Gildea rejected that framing, stating she had to accuse Canton police of “affirmative steps to encourage the achievement of the shared plan to direct the investigation towards her,” according to MassLive.

The conspiracy claim fell under G.L. c.

258, § 10(c), which excludes intentional torts from the Tort Claims Act’s liability provisions. Gildea treated civil conspiracy as an intentional tort, placing it outside what the town can be sued for under the Act, MassLegalResources reported.

Karen read canton conspiracy claim dismissed negligence surv
Photo: masslegalresources.com

The town argued the three-year statute of limitations began at Read’s arraignment on February 2, 2022. Gildea disagreed, noting Read’s lawsuit says she did not become aware of much of the evidence underlying the department’s negligence until after her acquittal, MassLive reported.

Canton also challenged the presentment letter Read sent in November 2025, claiming it was untimely and failed to specify the factual and legal bases of her claims.

Gildea said he was “not persuaded by either argument,” writing that the letter “makes clear that the basis of the negligence claim is the Town’s actions with respect to its employees,” MassLive reported.

The negligence claim alleges the town was negligent in hiring, training, supervising and retaining officers and in enforcing policies to safeguard evidence and prevent discrimination, MassLive reported. Under the Tort Claims Act, a public employer cannot be made to pay more than $100,000 on a negligence claim, MassLegalResources reported.

Read’s team consented “to avoid somewhat duplicative and inefficient litigation” in other courts without conceding their arguments, NBC Boston reported. The Globe reported that both investigators named in the complaint, former State Police Trooper Michael Proctor and former Canton police Sgt. Sean Goode, were forced out of their agencies.

Earlier this month, Massachusetts State Police accepted a judgment of $100,000 — the statutory maximum — to settle Read’s claims against the agency, NBC Boston reported. Read’s team consented “to avoid somewhat duplicative and inefficient litigation” in other courts, without conceding their arguments, NBC Boston reported.

Read was acquitted of charges connected to O’Keefe’s death and convicted on a drunken driving charge, for which she received probation. The estate of John O’Keefe has a separate wrongful-death lawsuit pending against Read.