Advance Colorado filed a lawsuit in Denver District Court on Thursday seeking to overturn Amendment 87, the graduated income tax measure voters approved this month with 51.72% of the vote.
The conservative nonprofit, representing Republican state Sens. Barbara Kirkmeyer and Byron Pelton, argues the measure violates the Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights by combining two constitutional changes in a single ballot question and that the state’s Blue Book voter guide misled thousands of taxpayers about the measure’s true cost.
Gov. Jared Polis and the director of the Colorado Department of Revenue are named as defendants. A Polis administration spokesperson declined to comment on the pending litigation.
“It’s clear that Amendment 87 should have been filed as two measures, not a single one,” Kirkmeyer said in a statement included in an Advance Colorado news release. “The constitution wasn’t followed, and voters will pay the price if this measure isn’t overturned.”
The Blue Book Dispute
The lawsuit centers on how the state calculates tax liability for residents earning income outside Colorado. The Department of Revenue uses total income to determine tax rates, while the Blue Book analysis relied on Colorado-sourced income alone. That methodological difference, the suit alleges, produced inaccurate projections for roughly 115,000 high earners.

Approximately 55,000 taxpayers earning between $500,000 and $1 million annually were told to expect an average tax cut of $284. Advance Colorado claims they face an average increase of roughly $2,600 instead. Another 60,000 taxpayers earning more than $1 million could see increases of approximately $39,000, not the $26,000 projected in the voter guide, according to the filing.
Amendment 87 impacts taxpayers in nine of the 12 new tax brackets. While the lawsuit acknowledges those earners will still save money, it argues the savings are smaller than the Blue Book indicated.
Amendment 87 Challenged Under TABOR Single-Subject Rule
The constitutional claim rests on TABOR’s requirement that tax increase questions appear as standalone measures. Advance Colorado contends Amendment 87 improperly bundled the removal of TABOR’s flat-tax mandate with the creation of a new six-tier graduated rate structure.
This marks the third legal attempt to stop the measure. The state Title Board and the Colorado Supreme Court previously allowed it on the ballot, rejecting a single-subject challenge in February. The high court also dismissed a petition-signature challenge.
Chris deGruy Kennedy, president of the Bell Policy Center, which helped lead the coalition supporting Amendment 87, said a previous legal effort to block the measure for violating the requirement that ballot measures only deal with one subject failed in February. He expects the measure will generate a “very healthy increase in funding” for K-12 education, healthcare, and early childhood programs.
The Medicaid Complication
The lawsuit quotes Polis telling the Joint Budget Committee on Nov. 12 that rising Medicaid costs could consume all new revenue from Amendment 87 within three years. “If you don’t rein in Medicaid, all of the 87 money goes to Medicaid. Zero for education, zero for actually making people healthier, zero for early childhood,” Polis said.
Colorado faces a more than $1 billion budget deficit driven partly by Medicaid growth. Lawmakers and education advocates say balancing new revenue with healthcare costs remains an open challenge.
Lawsuit Seeks to Block Tax Collection Under Amendment 87
The suit asks the court to block the Department of Revenue from collecting any additional taxes under Amendment 87. Lawrence Pacheco, a spokesperson for the Attorney General’s Office and Gov.-elect Phil Weiser, said they could not comment on a lawsuit they had not yet reviewed. Weiser opposed Amendment 87 during his campaign, citing its interaction with Proposition 136, a failed measure that would have capped the income tax rate at 4.4%.
Advance Colorado also filed several new ballot proposals Thursday aimed at reversing Amendment 87’s effects, including a flat 4.4% rate for earners above $100,000 and zero income tax below that threshold. The group’s president, Michael Fields, argued Colorado’s government has been growing faster than wages and that the state could still spend per capita at levels comparable to Nevada, North Carolina, and New Hampshire under the reduced revenue.
The allegations have not been established in court. A hearing date has not been set.