Artificial intelligence is transforming the way news is produced and consumed, posing a new set of challenges for local journalism in Hawaiʻi.
The state has already become one of the nation’s many news deserts, a reality that Honolulu Civil Beat reports is being complicated by an influx of automated content. Editors have faced a growing barrage of AI-generated emails ranging from offshore builders posing as future sources to marketing firms offering to automatically post stories on local sites.
One particularly striking pitch suggested a national effort to bring “daily local papers back to towns that lost theirs” by allowing anyone to become a publisher of an AI-powered news site for a starting price of $299, with no journalism experience required. While the Star-Advertiser continues to publish, the loss of local media outlets concerns the community.
“The future of news is a little scary. But it’s definitely not boring,” Jessica Terrell, Civil Beat managing editor, told Honolulu Civil Beat.
The current decline stands in stark contrast to the islands’ deep-seated media history. In the mid-1800s, Hawaiʻi possessed one of the highest literacy rates in the world, and residents were often more well-versed in global affairs than those in many parts of the United States.
Even as far back as May 11, 1865, the assassination of President Abraham Lincoln was front-page news when it reached the islands, according to the Papakilo Hawaiian Newspaper Database.
“Little rowboats would go out and pick up the newspapers they had collected from around the world,” local historian Anita Manning told Honolulu Civil Beat in 2019.
Between the mid-19th century and the turn of the millennium, more than 1,200 different newspapers were printed in the islands, including more than 100 published in ʻŌlelo Hawaiʻi. This collection of surviving Hawaiian language newspapers remains one of the largest repositories of Indigenous language material in the world.
The rise of fictitious journalists
As the industry shifts, the distinction between human reporting and machine-generated text is blurring. Research from a San Francisco marketing company suggests that AI now writes as many online articles as humans.
In Honolulu, the site Hoodline has faced scrutiny over its use of AI-generated personas. While some stories carry a byline for “Marc Suzuki,” there is no actual reporter by that name.
Although a small “ai” symbol appears next to the byline, it requires investigation to realize the name is a fictitious persona. A 2024 finding by Nieman Lab noted a trend where AI-generated names often shift to mirror local demographics to build unearned trust with a community.
The impact of AI extends beyond the writing itself to how audiences identify visual truth. Courtney Teague, director of audience at Civil Beat, has become a specialist in identifying AI-generated political imagery. During the 2026 campaign cycle, she estimated spotting at least a dozen AI-generated photos of political candidates.
“It just looks like a cartoon,” Teague told Honolulu Civil Beat, noting that AI-generated hair often looks too perfect or appears as a single piece when zoomed in.
“I hope that this isn’t too cynical, but I would just say assume it’s fake unless you know where it’s coming from,” Teague said.
The struggle for local news is also a battle of resources. While the number of nonprofit newsrooms in the U.S. grew from roughly 200 in 2015 to more than 400 last year, these outlets are now facing a digital transformation as disruptive as the arrival of the World Wide Web.
A shift in newsroom priorities
Journalists are attempting to pivot by using AI as a tool for efficiency rather than a replacement for human connection. Civil Beat is currently utilizing the technology to sort through thousands of hours of government meetings, allowing users to find and link to exact moments in legislative hearings. This approach aims to provide direct access to the sources of information rather than relying on filtered summaries.
The demographic shift in the media industry is also notable. As the number of journalists has declined over recent decades, the number of public relations professionals has grown remarkably. This imbalance has raised concerns among lawmakers regarding how public information is disseminated.
During a recent legislative hearing, State Sen. Joy San Buenaventura expressed skepticism regarding state spending on publicizing initiatives, such as the work of a no-bid contractor building homeless villages in Hawaiʻi. “Oh god, the public relations,” San Buenaventura told Honolulu Civil Beat.
The tension between automated efficiency and human-centric reporting remains unresolved. While some organizations lean into AI to manage the voracious data needs of the modern era, others are doubling down on local pipeline programs to nurture the next generation of reporters who can build the deep human connections that algorithms cannot replicate.