Alaska finished counting its outstanding ballots Wednesday evening, confirming Democrat Mary Peltola’s victory over Republican Senator Dan Sullivan in a race that drew national scrutiny over a namesake candidate and a federal lawsuit. Peltola captured 50.1 percent of first-choice votes to Sullivan’s 45.8 percent, clearing the majority threshold and avoiding a ranked-choice tabulation.
The Associated Press called the race Tuesday night at 10:19 p.m. Eastern time, ending a count that stretched from Election Day on November 3, Newsweek reported. Peltola, a Yup’ik Democrat and former congresswoman, becomes the first Alaska Native elected to the U.S. Senate and the first Democrat to win a Senate race in the state since 2008.
The Namesake Controversy That Drew Federal Intervention
The campaign was shadowed by the presence of a second Dan Sullivan on the ballot: Dan J. Sullivan Jr., a retired Petersburg schoolteacher with no party affiliation. Republicans alleged he was recruited as a spoiler to siphon votes from the incumbent. The New York Times reported last month that Peltola’s allies had recruited the retired teacher, a claim her campaign has denied.
Former Rep. Mary Peltola’s victory over Republican incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan in Alaska’s competitive U. S. Senate race has flipped a ninth Republican-held seat to the Democrats, giving Peltola’s party its biggest midterm gain in nearly 70 years. https://t.co/ldhEduxcmM
The Justice Department sued Alaska election officials on October 22, arguing that if the senator lost by fewer votes than his namesake received, certification should be blocked while investigators determined voter intent. On October 30, the department asked a judge to set aside every ballot ranking the namesake.
Newsweek reported that U.S. District Judge Sharon Gleason dismissed the suit on November 1, two days before the election, ruling the federal government lacked standing and that setting ballots aside would violate the right to a secret ballot.
In the final tally, Peltola’s margin exceeded the total votes cast for the retired teacher, rendering the spoiler scenario moot.
Yet the Justice Department has widened a criminal probe into the recruitment, sending letters to more than 20 Democrats informing them they might be targets or asking them to preserve records, and issuing hundreds of subpoenas, according to a person familiar with the investigation who spoke to The New York Times on condition of anonymity.
Certification Timeline and the Path to a Recount
Carol Beecher, the state’s director of elections, told reporters Wednesday that “we plan to certify the election, as per the law,” including the U.S. Senate race. The Division of Elections targets November 25 for certification after a review by the State Review Board.
Key dates that follow:
| Date | Milestone |
|---|---|
| November 25 | Target date for state certification of results |
| November 28 | Last day to seek a recount in the governor’s race |
| November 30 | Last day to seek a recount in the Senate race and most other contests |
| December 5 | Last day to challenge an outcome in state superior court |
| December 7 | Newly elected governor and lieutenant governor take office |
A candidate must request a recount within five days of state certification. The state pays only in races separated by less than 0.5 percent of the vote; otherwise, the requesting candidate covers the cost. With Peltola leading by roughly 4.3 percentage points, a state-funded recount is not triggered.
Sullivan Has Not Conceded
Senator Sullivan has not conceded. On Monday, his campaign said it would let the process run its course “until every legal vote is counted and certified” and promised to say more by the end of the week. Peltola’s campaign had already declared victory last week, writing on X that “there is no mathematical path for Sullivan to win this race.”

Spokesmen for Senator Sullivan and Governor Mike Dunleavy, a Republican who previously stopped short of saying the election should be certified for Peltola, did not respond to requests for comment on Wednesday, The New York Times reported.
House Seat Stays Republican
Wednesday’s count also settled Alaska’s single U.S. House seat. Representative Nick Begich III defeated Bill Hill, an independent supported by Democrats, keeping the seat in Republican hands.
Former Democratic Rep. Mary Peltola defeated GOP Sen. Dan Sullivan in the Alaska Senate race, CBS News projects, adding to the new Democratic majority in the Senate two weeks after Election Day. With the Alaska race now decided, Democrats will control 56 Senate seats to… pic.twitter.com/RpEX7PQm6S
What Remains Unresolved
The Justice Department’s criminal investigation into the recruitment of the retired teacher remains active. Republicans could still pursue further legal action after certification. And the Senate itself will ultimately decide on seating Peltola if a challenge reaches that stage.
Dan Sullivan, born in Fairview Park, Ohio, in 1964, graduated from Harvard University in 1987 and earned joint degrees from Georgetown University in 1993. He served as a Marine Corps infantry officer and reserve officer, deploying to Afghanistan in 2013 and retiring as a colonel in 2024.
Before winning his Senate seat in 2014, he was Alaska’s attorney general from 2009 to 2010 and commissioner of the Department of Natural Resources from 2010 to 2013. He also served as Assistant Secretary of State for Economic, Energy, and Business Affairs under President George W. Bush from 2006 to 2009.
“We plan to certify the election, as per the law,” Beecher told reporters Wednesday.
Democrat Mary Peltola will win the race for the U. S. Senate in Alaska, defeating incumbent Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan, The Associated Press projected. With Peltola's victory, Democrats flipped nine Senate seats, the most since 1958. Republicans entered the midterms with a… pic.twitter.com/jFuN6UX9PZ
Peltola defeats Sullivan in Alaska Senate race, expanding Democratic majority ➡️ https://t.co/fJO9N0aVwG pic.twitter.com/aqym9K87zd