The arrest of Brian Arnall on November 17 comes 719 days after Henry was last seen alive at the Primrose Marketplace on South Glenstone Avenue, a gap that turned a missing-person search into a homicide investigation spanning two Thanksgiving seasons.
“It’s not necessarily the outcome we hoped for or wanted,” Letitia Henry, Chance’s sister, told KY3. “We’ve spent the last 719 days, just 11 days short of two years after he went missing, looking for him, asking questions, keeping his name out there. And somewhere in our distant mind, we hoped he met a girl, was off on a beach somewhere, living his life.”
The timeline: vanished in November, reported in February
Police believe Henry, 37, was shot and killed on the afternoon of November 29, 2024, inside a vehicle in or near the Primrose Marketplace parking lot in the 3400 block of South Glenstone Avenue, according to an SPD news release cited by the News-Leader. His family did not report him missing until February 27, 2025 — three months later.
Captain Culley Wilson told KY3 that probable cause for the arrest developed recently, though he declined to detail the specific evidence because the investigation remains open.

A suspect in custody, a body still missing
Arnall was booked into the Greene County Jail on November 17 and was being held without bond as of Wednesday afternoon, the News-Leader reported. A Casenet search of his name did not return results of any past violent crime charges.
KY3 is not naming the suspect until formal charges are filed, though the News-Leader identified him as Arnall based on the police announcement. Both outlets confirm the arrest stems from the same SPD investigation.
“We have not found Mr. Henry’s body,” Captain Wilson told KY3. “We’re right now actively searching for it, but we need more information if the public or anyone out there knows more about this. We know that the suspect has intimidated some folks and may be scared to come forward. If that’s the case, you can tell us about it; you can be anonymous.”
The family’s push for recovery
“There’s a lot of anger and a lot of hope for justice in this situation because there’s an individual who has spent this time living their life while my brother’s life was taken. We really want justice.”
— Letitia Henry, Chance Henry’s sister, speaking to KY3
The family is still offering a reward for information leading to the recovery of Chance’s body. “If you know anything at all, even something that you may think is very small, if you’ve seen something or heard something, if you were in that area of the Primrose Marketplace on that day, please don’t feel like it’s a silly thing; call the police department,” Letitia Henry said.
Police are asking anyone with information to contact the Springfield Police Department at 417-864-1810 or submit an anonymous tip through Crime Stoppers at 417-869-8477.