Alex Gibney’s ‘Musk’ Relies on an Uncanny AI Avatar That Obscures More Than It Reveals

Alex Gibney’s four-hour documentary Musk opens with a simulation, but the most synthetic thing in the film isn’t the subject’s theory of reality—it’s the director’s choice to build an AI stand-in for the billionaire himself.

Three hours and fifteen minutes into the runtime, a video-game avatar of Elon Musk picks up a chainsaw from the Resolute Desk in a first-person shooter sequence, lightning arcing from the blade as it destroys government buildings labeled USDA, 404 Media reported.

But the AI avatar—rendered with an oversized head, exaggerated features, and seated in a gamer chair bathed in dated Twitch-stream lighting—appears throughout as a simulated interviewer. Gibney told the International Documentary Association he leaned into the "air of unreality" because Musk believes we live in an ancestor simulation, using the avatar to "explore the tools of deception and manipulation to get out the other side."

In practice, the device backfires. Every line the AI Musk speaks is a direct quote from real interviews—with Jordan Peterson for The Daily Wire, Bill Maher on Real Time, Kara Swisher, Joe Rogan, and at CPAC—and in every instance the original footage, with its context and crosstalk, is more revealing than the approximation.

When the avatar recites Musk’s line about his estranged daughter Vivian—”They call it dead naming because, uh, your son is dead. So my son is dead. Killed by the woke mind virus”—the Peterson interview’s tension vanishes. When it paraphrases the “most entertaining outcome” catchphrase, the Swisher and Rogan dynamics disappear.

The Video-Game Metaphor Feels Like a Boomer Grasp at Gen-Z Aesthetics

The interstitials lean hard on a pink-filtered, Grand Theft Auto VI-style visual language. The avatar selects character classes—gamer, founder, Kublai Khan—drives a digital track where Tesla’s stock price rises like a high score, and vaporizes Twitter employees with Iron Man gauntlets.

The DOGE chainsaw rampage ends with a nuke dropped on the National Nuclear Safety Administration and the inauguration salute rendered as a pixel-art score screen. The film even includes an intermission during streaming, reinforcing the sense of a marathon that mistakes length for gravity.

Berlin germany boris becker and alex gibney pose at the boom boom the world vs boris becker

After publication, Musk’s public relations team reached out to 404 Media to say the avatar was built with CGI and hand-designed, and that AI was only used to sync sound to the image, a representative from Falco Ink told the outlet.

Gibney told Edward Niedermeyer the process involved an AI artist at Makemake and considerable refinement, not a generative “press a button” workflow. The distinction does not change the on-screen result: a hyperreal grotesque that distracts from the documentary’s central argument that Musk is a destructive force in business and politics.

“You need to embrace the air of unreality in order to bring a sense of reality to bear. You have to explore the tools of deception and manipulation to get out the other side. That’s why we came up with the AI avatar of Elon Musk.”

Alex Gibney, director, told the International Documentary Association

Falco Ink

Gibney has made a career of penetrating powerful institutions—Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room, Going Clear, The Inventor. Here, the subject refused to participate, and the workaround becomes the story.

The avatar doesn’t deepen the portrait; it sanitizes it, replacing the friction of real interviews with a compliant digital puppet that grins evilly on cue. The chainsaw sequence at the three-hour mark isn’t satire—it’s the film indulging the very simulation logic Musk sells, leaving the viewer further from the man than when they started.