Vermont lawmakers passed a new statute this year that bars families in towns without public high schools from using state tuition aid at religious schools, Catholic World Report reported.
The law, known as Act 73, took effect July 1, 2025, after Gov. Phil Scott signed the 147-page measure. It disqualified all 15 previously eligible faith-based schools from the state’s dual-enrollment program while allowing 45 secular private schools to continue participating.
On Oct. 27, 2026, Alliance Defending Freedom filed suit in federal court on behalf of Carrie and Greg Bishop and their daughter, A.B., a senior at Mount St. Joseph Academy in Rutland.
The complaint says the family’s Barstow Unified Union School District refused to cover A.B.’s tuition under the old law’s grandfather clause after she “fell into depression and struggled emotionally and spiritually” when forced to leave the Catholic school.
“Mrs. Bishop had to take ‘a second job to help pay for A.B.’s tuition this year,’” the filing says. “As a result, Carrie has had to spend more time away from home and less time with A.B., thus detrimentally impeding her ability to nurture and raise A.B.”
The Bishops, who are not Catholic, homeschooled their three daughters through eighth grade before enrolling them at Mount St. Joseph to align with their Christian faith. They said their son’s experience in public schools grew “increasingly more antagonistic and hostile to their religious beliefs.”
Act 73 imposes three new requirements: a school must be located where at least one district does not operate its own secondary school; 25 percent of its student body must have been publicly funded in the 2023-24 school year; and secondary schools must meet a minimum class size of 18.
Faith-based schools were barred from the tuitioning program until the Supreme Court’s 2022 ruling in Carson v. Makin, making the 2023-24 threshold effectively impossible to meet.
The complaint raises three constitutional claims. First, Act 73 violates the Free Exercise Clause because it is neither neutral nor generally applicable and triggers strict scrutiny. Second, it infringes the Fourteenth Amendment right of parents to direct the upbringing of their children, a right recognized in Pierce v. Society of Sisters (1925). Third, it denies equal protection by treating families at religious schools less favorably than those at secular private schools.
The plaintiffs seek preliminary and permanent injunctions ordering the district to pay A.B.’s tuition for the 2026-27 year, allowing her to participate in the dual-enrollment program for spring 2027, and blocking enforcement of Act 73’s religious exclusion. They also request a declaratory judgment, nominal and compensatory damages, and attorney’s fees.
The Supreme Court has decided three major cases since 2017 establishing that states cannot exclude religious institutions from generally available public benefits. In Trinity Lutheran Church v. Comer (2017), Chief Justice John Roberts wrote that denying a church a playground-resurfacing grant “solely because it is a church, is odious to our Constitution.”
In Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue (2020), the Court struck down a state constitutional ban on aid to “sectarian schools” as lacking a compelling interest. In Carson v. Makin (2022), the Court invalidated Maine’s exclusion of sectarian schools from a similar tuitioning program.
Alliance Defending Freedom, founded in 1993 by a group of conservative Christian leaders that included James Dobson and D. James Kennedy, shifted from funding outside lawyers to direct litigation in 2012. By 2014 it employed more than 40 staff attorneys and has since represented parties in 15 Supreme Court victories, including the 2022 Carson v. Makin decision that underpins the Bishops’ claims.
Vermont’s new criteria — location, prior public funding, and class size — appear designed to achieve the same exclusion through ostensibly neutral standards that religious schools cannot meet. The case is Bishop v. Saunders, pending in the U.S. District Court for the District of Vermont.