Analysts Debate Replacing Daniel Jones With Anthony Richardson

by

The Indianapolis Colts are staring down a familiar, uncomfortable reality.

Following a 27-23 loss to the Dallas Cowboys on November 8, 2026, the team finds itself reeling from yet another dropped game at Lucas Oil Stadium. While the margin was not as severe as their 42-7 defeat to the Jacksonville Jaguars in Week 8, the result has intensified scrutiny regarding the team’s leadership under center.

Quarterback Daniel Jones finished the contest against Dallas with a 58.8% completion rate, completing 20 of 34 passes for 180 yards, one touchdown, and one interception. The 29-year-old starter appeared visibly frustrated during his postgame press conference as the organization continues to struggle. Analysts have suggested that Jones has repeatedly demonstrated he is not the solution for the Colts, particularly as the team’s season is considered lost.

The Colts possess a 24-year-old alternative in Anthony Richardson Sr., who is currently in his fourth NFL season. Selected by Indianapolis with the No. 4 overall pick in the 2023 NFL draft following a collegiate career with the Florida Gators, Richardson has seen very limited action this year. His statistical output for the current season stands at two completions on two attempts for eight yards in a single game.

Richardson’s most active professional season occurred in 2024, when he appeared in 11 games. During that campaign, he completed 126 of 264 passes (47.7%) for 1,814 yards, recording eight passing touchdowns and 12 interceptions.

The debate over a change at quarterback centers on whether the team should prioritize immediate stability or future development. Zachary Rotman of FanSided argued that because the season is already lost, the team has little to lose by giving Richardson more opportunities. According to Rotman, playing the younger quarterback could reveal if he is the team’s 2027 solution or if the franchise must seek a new quarterback during the upcoming offseason.

“Jones has proven time and time again that he is not the solution under center for the Colts,” Zachary Rotman of FanSided said.

Analysts Debate Replacing Daniel Jones With Anthony Richardson

While some suggest Richardson might not provide a massive boost, others argue he could be enough to keep the team afloat while Jones continues to sink with the organization. The question remains whether the Colts will move to replace Jones with Richardson immediately.

Related reading

Read next