Appeals Court Rejects Democrat LaMonica McIver’s Bid to Toss Charges Over ICE Protest

A federal appeals court on Thursday refused to rehear the case against Representative LaMonica McIver, leaving the New Jersey Democrat on track for trial on charges she assaulted federal officers during an oversight visit to an ICE detention center last May.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 3rd Circuit denied McIver’s petition for an en banc review, letting stand an August panel decision that rejected her claim of legislative immunity under the Constitution’s Speech or Debate Clause.

The ruling came one day after McIver confronted Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin at a House hearing, telling him, “You are killing people,” over conditions at the same facility, Delaney Hall.

“Because of a weaponized Department of Justice, and because I dared to do my job and conduct oversight of ICE, I am facing 17 years in prison,” McIver said in a statement Thursday.

“Now, due to the disappointing decision by the third circuit, we are all one step closer to a world in which the president of the United States can try to imprison people simply because he does not like what they stand for.”

Us news congress mciver charges filepic get
Photo: courant.com

The August ruling that set the stage

A divided three-judge panel ruled 2-1 in August that two of the three charges against McIver — assaulting, resisting, or impeding federal officers, and interfering with a federal officer — involved conduct “unambiguously non-legislative” in nature.

Judge Cindy Chung wrote for the majority that the Speech or Debate Clause protects legislative acts, not physical confrontations with law enforcement. The panel sent the third charge, assault on a federal officer, back to U.S. District Judge Jamel Semper for further consideration of whether that specific allegation might touch on protected activity.

Judge Thomas Ambro dissented in part, arguing the trial court should first hold an evidentiary hearing to determine exactly what McIver did and whether the prosecution was motivated by political retaliation. “I would allow her discovery into the truth of the matter — not only for her own sake but to safeguard the independence of our legislative bodies,” Ambro wrote.

Judge Emil Bove, a former Trump administration official and personal attorney for the president, recused himself from the en banc vote. Three active judges voted to grant rehearing; the majority did not.

What happened at Delaney Hall

The charges stem from a May 2025 oversight visit to Delaney Hall, a large ICE detention center in Newark. McIver arrived with two other members of Congress and Newark Mayor Ras Baraka. Federal officials barred the delegation from entering. Outside the facility, agents moved to arrest Baraka for trespassing after he refused to leave.

According to a Homeland Security agent’s declaration, McIver intervened, “slammed her forearm” into one agent and “forcibly” struck another deportation officer with her forearms. Baraka was charged with trespassing, but prosecutors later dropped those charges. McIver is the only elected official facing prosecution.

Appeals Court Rejects Democrat LaMonica McIver's Bid to Toss Charges Over ICE Protest
Photo: rollcall.com

“Donald Trump continues to send warning shots to Democrats in Congress and in all levels of power — but their case against me right now, in broad daylight, goes well beyond a warning,” McIver said Thursday.

A facility under scrutiny

Delaney Hall has drawn repeated scrutiny since ICE resumed detaining immigrants there in 2025. At least three detainees have died at the facility. Earlier this year, the site saw major clashes during protests supporting a hunger strike by detainees.

At Wednesday’s House hearing, McIver pressed Mullin on the deaths and conditions inside. Mullin said he had visited Delaney Hall and found it in “very good condition.” McIver replied, “History is going to judge you for what you are doing.”

Legal team reviews options including Supreme Court petition

McIver said her legal team is examining “every possible option,” including a petition to the U.S. Supreme Court. The case returns to Judge Semper in Newark for further proceedings on the remaining assault charge and trial preparation on the two counts the appeals court affirmed. No trial date has been set.