Arizona Man Sentenced to 12 Years for Enticing 12-Year-Old Girl Met on Fortnite

An Arizona man who met a 12-year-old Idaho girl through Fortnite was sentenced to four years fixed and eight years indeterminate in prison, a term that exceeded the prosecution's plea agreement recommendation and showed how online gaming platforms remain hunting grounds for predators.

District Judge Daniel Clark handed down the sentence in Jefferson County after a psychosexual evaluation flagged Arhen Neil Heineman, 30, as a high risk to reoffend and indicated he had been deceptive during a polygraph about prior sexual contact with minors, eastidahonews.com reported.

The case, investigated jointly by the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office, the Pinal County Sheriff’s Office in Arizona and the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, began when the victim gave a family member’s phone number to Heineman after he asked for her personal contact information.

The messages that triggered the investigation

Court documents detail sexually explicit conversations in which Heineman stated he did not care that the victim was 12. Deputies photographed the message thread after the family member — posing as the girl — received what they described as “sick, gross things that he was going to do to (the victim),” according to eastidahonews.com. A warrant was obtained and Heineman was arrested in Arizona City, Arizona.

Arizona Man Sentenced to 12 Years for Enticing 12-Year-Old Girl Met on Fortnite
Photo: aol.com

Sentencing clash: rider program versus prison

Heineman signed a plea agreement on June 23 in which the state would argue for no more than five years fixed, though the deal was non-binding on the court.

At the November 2 hearing, defense attorney Roger J. Hoopes challenged the psychosexual evaluation, arguing it overstated his client’s criminal history by treating two dismissed Arizona charges as convictions and omitting that Heineman had completed probation without violations. Hoopes asked for a retained jurisdiction — Idaho’s rider program — to allow access to treatment and schooling.

Chief Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Scott Peterson acknowledged Heineman’s cooperation but emphasized the evaluator’s finding that Heineman claimed sexual interest in women aged 21 to 35, a profile that contradicted the “calculated solicitation of a 12-year-old child.” Peterson read from the evaluation: “This discrepancy further evidences ongoing effort to sanitize his clinical profile and deny his deviant behavior.” He requested 15 years with five years fixed.

“You knowingly sought out and attempted to elicit provocative pictures and sexual conversations with a 12-year-old. That’s prison conduct, period.”

Judge Daniel Clark

Clark agreed with the prosecution’s risk assessment. He noted the polygraph results showing deception about whether Heineman had ever had sex with a minor or engaged in explicit conversations with other minors.

“The question then becomes: With that coupled with the evaluation, does that place you in a position where your risk is either something that can be managed within a retained jurisdiction, or managed on a community-based placement?” Clark asked. “The psychosexual evaluator says no, at least based on the risk, and the pre-sentence investigator says no.”

Heineman apologizes, seeks plea withdrawal

Before sentencing, Heineman addressed the court: “Everybody makes mistakes, your honor, and some people make worse mistakes than others. However, anybody can change if they genuinely want to.” He said he had apologized to the victim, vowed to God to never drink alcohol again and dedicated his life to healing the wounds he inflicted.

After hearing the 12-year sentence, Heineman told the court he wanted to withdraw his guilty plea; Clark directed him to speak with his attorney about filing the appropriate motions.

The sentence requires Heineman to register as a sex offender.