HSE chief executive Anne O’Connor appeared before the Oireachtas health committee Wednesday and acknowledged she has not spoken recently to Cork University Hospital CEO Jennifer Kearney, despite a staffing and safety dispute simmering since August.
Sinn Féin health spokesman David Cullinane called it “extraordinary” and said the priority must be to “sort out the hospital” in relation to staff shortages and overcrowding.
O’Connor Criticises CUH Media Engagement
In her opening statement, O’Connor said CUH was “not unique in facing huge service pressures” but was “unique in that it appears to be conducting its management business via the media with extraordinary regularity”. She also told the committee that staff at CUH were “fearful” of attending meetings because they believed they were being recorded without their knowledge.
Labour TD Eoghan Kenny pressed O’Connor on whether the position of HSE South West regional executive officer Dr Andy Philips was tenable after a recording emerged of a meeting between Philips and Kearney.
O’Connor said Philips had apologised for his comments, which he attributed to the heat of the moment, but she declined to say whether she had full confidence in him, stating “I’m not going to get into that in this forum, there’s work underway within the region”.
Taoiseach and Minister Reject ‘Unsafe’ Label
Taoiseach Micheál Martin told the Dáil he had dismissed nothing, pointing to a process and insisting staffing levels at CUH had increased by almost 50 per cent since 2020.

Minister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill rejected suggestions that CUH was unsafe. She cited an interim HSE patient safety assessment that found the overall position “broadly reassuring”, and said the Health Information and Quality Authority, which inspected CUH in recent weeks, had “not identified any red flags”.
Opposition Warns of ‘Chilling Effect’
Social Democrats deputy leader Cian O’Callaghan accused the Government of a “dismiss, deflect, repeat” approach. He said CUH clinicians were “begging for help” but the HSE response was “essentially ‘get back in your box’”, calling it “a classic case of shoot the messenger in order to deflect from the serious concerns about patient safety and to deter staff in other hospitals from speaking out”.
Staffing Numbers and Overcrowding
O’Connor told the committee the HSE payroll system shows CUH’s staffing numbers, including those recruited and in the recruitment process. Committee chair Padraig Rice countered that payroll data alone did not reflect how many staff were actually on the wards and available to the hospital.
On Wednesday, 73 patients waited on trolleys for a bed at the embattled Cork hospital due to overcrowding. The hospital had 70 patients waiting on trolleys on Monday morning.
Recorded Meeting and Legal Questions
The dispute intensified after a recording of a meeting between Kearney and Philips was published. In it, Philips said he had been instructed by the Taoiseach’s office and the Minister’s office to have “some very specific conversations” with Kearney. He later apologised for his comments. O’Connor said she was “concerned about the minutes” of that meeting but had not listened to the recording.
Labour health spokeswoman Marie Sherlock questioned the legal basis for the Minister’s intervention in hospital staffing, noting that legislation passed 22 years ago gave hospital managers and clinicians the power to decide staffing and operations. She said the Department of Health appeared to be inserting itself into internal HSE recruitment decisions in a way that departed from the Health Act 2004.
Martin criticised the recording of the meeting, saying he was “very concerned” and that issues at CUH would not be solved by “megaphone engagement”. He said he had been involved with the hospital for nearly 30 years and did not recall meetings ever being recorded.
Calls for Mediation and Independent Review
Mayor of the County of Cork, Cllr Bernard Moynihan, urged the appointment of a mediator and said independent oversight was needed to resolve the issues between CUH management and the HSE.
O’Connor said information was being shared through regional structures. She acknowledged that HSE South West had expressed concerns this week that its applications for recruitment approvals were not being processed quickly enough. The Minister’s office has not responded to questions about the alleged instructions.