Arkansas Supreme Court Justice Cody Hiland told a Senate committee Wednesday he would not say who won the popular vote in the 2020 presidential election, even as he acknowledged Joe Biden’s Electoral College victory.
Democrats have pressed Trump judicial nominees on the question for years, treating the answer as a proxy for fidelity to democratic norms. Hiland, a former state Republican Party chairman, said the popular vote “is not what’s important” and that answering would drag him “down a political track on an issue that happened six years ago” and risk an ethical violation.
Sen. Richard Blumenthal pressed Hiland twice. Hiland held his ground. “I think it’s going down a political track on an issue that happened six years ago and I don’t want to come close to a potential ethical violation,” he said.
The exchange framed a hearing that also touched on a bar-exam tampering scandal on Hiland’s court and his own description of himself as “belligerent” in turning down a district-court nomination. Sen. Dick Durbin, the committee’s top Democrat, said he had “deep concerns” about Hiland’s partisan background and a state Supreme Court ruling allowing the legislature to alter voter-approved constitutional amendments.
Durbin accused Republicans of rushing nominees before Democrats take Senate control in January. “Just eight days after the committee’s last nominations hearing, we’re back again because Senate Republicans are determined to confirm as many nominees as possible before control of the Senate shifts in six weeks,” Durbin said in a statement.
Durbin asked Hiland about the arrest of the former executive director of the Arkansas Supreme Court’s Office of Professional Programs, charged with tampering with bar exam scores between 2020 and 2025. Hiland, who joined the court in 2023, said he learned of the investigation in May. “We’re trying to get our hands around exactly what the universe of the problem is,” he said, denying any personal role.
Hiland also addressed remarks he made to law students in August, when he said he was “belligerent” in telling the White House he did not want a district-court seat. On Wednesday he called the word a mistake.
“This was a 10-minute, extemporaneous speech to first year law students. When we speak extemporaneously, sometimes we use words we shouldn’t,” Hiland said. “The proper word was probably resolute as it relates to being an appellate court judge versus the other.”
Arkansas’ two Republican senators vouched for Hiland. “Justice Hiland’s legal experience, his track record from both the bench and the lawyer’s table, and his unwavering respect for the rule of law make him an ideal candidate for this position,” Sen. Tom Cotton said introducing him.
Sen. John Boozman cited Hiland’s “extensive legal experience, sound judgement and a commitment to upholding the law rather than legislating from the bench.”
The 8th Circuit covers Arkansas, Iowa, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota and South Dakota. Trump withdrew his prior nominee, U.S. District Judge Lee Rudofsky, before naming Hiland.
The committee has not scheduled a vote.