“I thought we had fixed it, and obviously, we hadn’t,” Republican Sen. Steve Crowell of Magnolia said Tuesday, calling the 2025 law a mistake that had to be corrected.
A bipartisan coalition of eight Republicans and two Democrats filed legislation Monday to repeal the Generating Arkansas Jobs Act of 2025, a measure signed by Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders that lets utilities charge ratepayers for power plants before they are built.
Senate Bill 2, introduced by Senate Majority Whip Clint Penzo of Springdale, would erase the “strategic investment rider” mechanism that began appearing on Entergy Arkansas bills this year to cover three generation projects, including one tied to Google’s West Memphis data center.
The repeal push marks a striking reversal for a Republican-dominated Legislature that passed the law last year on the promise it would attract energy-intensive industry while smoothing out rate increases.
Instead, lawmakers say the first round of extra charges landed on residential bills before any new electrons flowed, and the utility isn’t directly applying the hundreds of millions Google is paying Entergy to the construction costs those riders are meant to fund.
“Arkansas needs laws to enable market-based solutions that encourage new generation, protect existing ratepayers, and ensure we can meet growing energy demand without sacrificing affordability,”
The mechanism that triggered the backlash
The 2025 act inverted the traditional regulatory compact. Before its passage, utilities could only recover construction costs after a plant went online. The new law created a “strategic investment rider” — a line-item surcharge that lets Entergy and other utilities collect those costs upfront. Supporters, including the governor and utility companies, argued this gradual approach would insulate customers from the rate shock of a single large increase once a plant entered service.

Critics countered that the rider transfers all construction risk — cost overruns, delays, or cancellation — onto captive ratepayers while guaranteeing the utility a return on equity for capital it hasn’t yet deployed. Those concerns moved from theoretical to concrete in recent months when Entergy Arkansas customers saw the first charges for three gas-fired plants.
One of those units is slated to serve Google’s data center in West Memphis. The tech giant is paying Entergy hundreds of millions of dollars to secure that power, but lawmakers questioned in September why those payments weren’t being credited directly against the rider charges appearing on residential bills.
Former sponsor joins utility group as Entergy ex-CEO becomes commerce secretary
The political optics have sharpened the criticism. The bill’s original sponsor, former Republican Sen. Jonathan Dismang of Searcy, resigned his seat this year to become vice president of external affairs for Arkansas Electric Cooperatives. Meanwhile, Entergy Arkansas’ former CEO, Hugh McDonald, now serves as the state’s commerce secretary under Sanders. Both moves were highlighted as lawmakers questioned whether the law was written for industry rather than consumers.
Entergy spokesperson Matt Ramsey said the utility would monitor the repeal bill but declined to say whether the company opposes it. “Our priority is to work with the members of the General Assembly to answer questions and address any concerns about how the law works and the benefits it provides to customers,” Ramsey said in a statement.

A governor’s non-answer
Sanders’ office stopped short of defending the law she signed. Spokesperson Sam Dubke did not say whether the governor supports the repeal effort.
“Arkansas’ energy infrastructure is aging and needs to be upgraded or replaced to maintain the grid our citizens rely on, and Governor Sanders looks forward to working with the legislature to make those necessary investments while still keeping Arkansas’ utility rates among the lowest in the nation,” Dubke said in a statement.
The carefully worded response leaves the administration room to negotiate a replacement framework rather than a clean repeal. Penzo’s SB 2 strips the rider provisions entirely, but other legislation may emerge when the General Assembly convenes Jan. 11 for a session expected to run through April.
Regret across the aisle
Crowell, who initially declined to vote for the act before supporting an amended version, joined Texarkana Republican Sen. Jimmy Hickey in expressing public regret. Hickey is a cosponsor of the repeal; Crowell is not, saying he wants to see what other proposals surface.
“I don’t know if there’s anything we can do but repeal it,” Crowell said. “Again, I think it’s prudent to think about all the options, but I don’t feel that the people of Arkansas are going to want us to keep this in place.”
The Democratic cosponsors — Sen. Jamie Scott of North Little Rock and Sen.-elect Tara Shephard of Little Rock show a rare bipartisan consensus on a utility issue that usually splits along party lines. No House members have signed on yet.
“Concerns about the 2025 law have only grown since its passage. A full repeal of the law is necessary — as is a broader conversation about energy policy,”
Lawmakers return to the Capitol on Jan. 11.