Leon County Commissioners Unanimously Approve Framework to Resolve Fire Service Dispute With Tallahassee

Leon County commissioners voted unanimously Monday to approve a framework that could end a two-year fight with Tallahassee over fire service fees, sending the deal to a City Commission vote Wednesday.

The memorandum of understanding passed on a voice vote after a special called meeting. Chair Christian Caban, Vice Chair David O’Keefe, and Commissioners Bill Proctor, Nick Maddox, Brian Welch, Rick Minor, and Carolyn Cummings backed it. “Look how easy this could have been. We spent two years wasting everybody’s time,” O’Keefe said.

The agreement would keep the city providing fire rescue in unincorporated Leon County while rewriting the financial and operational terms that have sparked lawsuits and dueling termination notices since 2025. If the City Commission approves the MOU Wednesday, the county will withdraw its notice ending the current contract and extend it one year to September 2029 while staff negotiate a long-term deal.

Tallahassee city hall via tallahassee democrat
Photo: floridapolitics.com

“When I gavel out of this meeting, I want us to turn the page with the fighting with the City of Tallahassee,” Caban said.

The election that changed the math

The framework emerged nine days after the November 3 city election flipped the Tallahassee City Commission to a 3-2 progressive majority and ushered in Mayor Jeremy Matlow. Caban negotiated the deal with Matlow after a private meeting on November 10, announcing the framework November 12. Matlow told WTXL the framework “doesn’t give everybody everything they want, but it will relieve public anxiety over the future of fire service.”

Until that election, the previous commission — John Dailey, Dianne Williams-Cox, and Curtis Richardson — had voted 3-2 to adopt a 10% fee increase in September 2025 and then voted 3-2 to end the interlocal agreement when it expires. Dailey later told the City Commission he was not spending “any more time on this junk that’s coming out of the county,” according to the Tallahassee Democrat.

‘A new era’: Tallahassee, county officials announce proposed fire services agreement — WCTV Eyewitness News

Stations, schedules, and the $20 million cap

Under the MOU, the county would purchase Fire Stations 10 through 15 for about $1.9 million and lease them back to the city for $1 a year, with closing targeted for September 2027. A new south-side Fire Station 17 would be capped at $20 million. The deal also writes an automatic aid agreement — dispatching the closest station regardless of jurisdiction — into the long-term contract, replacing the 1988 interlocal agreement last amended in 2023.

Firefighters would move to a 24/72 work schedule, effectively a 42-hour work week. County staff estimate that change alone could raise department costs 18% to 20%, a figure that would feed into a new joint rate study conducted every three years instead of every five. Any rate change would require approval from both commissions.

Leon County Commissioners Unanimously Approve Framework to Resolve Fire Service Dispute With Tallahassee
Photo: wctv.tv

“There will probably be some increases to the fire service fee for the folks in the county, but look at what we are going to get for that,” Welch said. “We’re going to get a 42-hour work week for firefighters. We’re now going to have protections in owning fire stations 10-15.”

The bill for the breakup

The dispute has already carried a price tag. The county hired Fitch & Associates in December 2025 for $109,995 to study a county-run department. Fitch put the cost at roughly $30 million if the county bought the six city stations, or about $95 million without an automatic aid agreement, the Tallahassee Democrat reported.

County Attorney Chasity O’Steen said a review by consulting firm Benesch found a potential shortfall of $15 million to $21.2 million in fire fee revenue for fiscal years 2024 and 2025; the county paid Benesch $87,615.

Both governments had issued notices ending the current agreement. Mediation on the county’s claims is expected in December. Once a long-term agreement is fully executed, the two governments release each other from all disputed claims.

What happens Wednesday

The City Commission takes up the MOU at its 3 p.m. meeting Wednesday. If approved, staff will negotiate a detailed contract expected back before the County Commission by March 2027. County Administrator Vincent Long said the one-year contract extension gives the county time to pursue its own department if talks collapse.

Proctor, the county’s longest-tenured local elected official, seconded Caban’s motion Monday. He noted the south-side station has languished since around 2015. “We are meeting, hopefully, with this MOU halfway,” Cummings said. “City, County, and that’s clearly in the best interest of our citizens, the best interest of our firefighters who provide that safety net for all of us.”