City assessors presented by Vice President Sara Duterte’s defense failed to establish conclusively that questioned properties in Davao City and Samal Island were properly declared in her statements of assets, liabilities, and net worth, Rep. Terry Ridon said on Wednesday.
Ridon, a House impeachment prosecutor, said that discrepancies involving property locations, values, and supporting paperwork remained entirely unresolved despite testimony given before the Senate impeachment court. The defense initially introduced Davao City Assessor Jaime Adalin on November 9 to prove that a 379-square-meter property registered under the Vice President’s husband, lawyer Manases Carpio, already appeared in her filings.
Adalin identified tax declarations corresponding to an entry in Duterte’s sworn declaration. Questions quickly surfaced, however, over a P6-million amount appearing in the prosecution property records contrasted against a P10-million selling price reflected in the deed of sale.
Additional complications emerged regarding valuation gaps. Addressing a list of properties in Barangay 74-A, Davao City, prosecutor Amando Ligutan said that extra expenses incurred during acquisition do not explain a P4 million discrepancy in the declared value of the Matina Crossing property.
“It’s not good for a party to end up with that conclusion. If you want to prove they’re the same property, that’s fine. But when your witness themself says, ‘They might be (the same property)’ then, upon probing, says, ‘They also might not be (the same property),’ that’s a disaster,” Ligutan said.

The defense then presented Island Garden City of Samal Assessor John Kenneth Enumerables on November 10 to explain another property registered to Carpio. Enumerables confirmed that the property covered by a transfer certificate of title sits in Barangay San Isidro, Kaputian, carrying an assessed value of P346,960 and a market value of P4,956,600.
Duterte’s filing listed the location as Barangay Matanos, Kaputian. During questioning, Enumerables acknowledged that no Barangay Matanos actually exists within the Island Garden City of Samal.
“How did you become an assessor if you don’t know the location?” Senator-judge Erwin Tulfo asked.
Enumerables relied instead on matching assessed and market values to argue that the documents pointed to the same asset. The witness also acknowledged that Duterte’s filings lacked the title or assessment record numbers that could directly establish a connection.

The testimony left core doubts intact regarding whether the properties identified by the prosecution matched the assets detailed in Duterte’s sworn disclosures. “But from the testimony of the witnesses themselves, they could not tell with certainty if they were one and the same property,” Rep. Terry Ridon said.
The prosecution previously questioned whether assets registered under Carpio had been accurately and completely disclosed. The defense maintains that the disputed holdings were already declared, utilizing official tax records to establish their identities.
The Senate impeachment court will ultimately determine whether the submitted documents and witness testimony sufficiently establish proper disclosure.