When a coal plant shuts down in rural Arizona, the loss isn’t measured only in megawatts — it shows up in empty classroom seats, canceled Fourth of July parades, and family budgets that suddenly don’t stretch far enough.
Arizona State University’s Just Energy Transition Center has been documenting the fallout and released a policy brief arguing the state has no real safety net for towns left behind, ASU News reported.
“It’s not fair to take the water, the land, the air of rural communities, and then when the plants close, turn our backs,” Amanda Ormond, the center’s director, told ASU News. “We need to support people.”
The fiscal cliff no one tracks
Coal plants are typically the largest taxpayer in their county and the largest taxpayer for the school system. When the Navajo Generating Station closed in 2019, the Navajo Nation lost an estimated 1,000 jobs and $40 million in annual revenue, according to the Navajo Times. Yet Arizona’s tax structure makes it impossible to quantify the exact hit for the next closure.
Counties receive an amount of money for taxes, but it’s not broken out by assets, so officials don’t know how much money comes from a coal plant versus another industrial facility. Ormond noted the center would like to be able to tell a community, “Apache County is losing $4.26 million over a 10-year period from this coal plant,” but that data simply doesn’t exist under current law.
The advisory committee’s first recommendation is to designate a state agency responsible for helping communities — something the governor could do without legislation. Other early steps include commissioning studies so you can tell what the fiscal and job impacts of closures are and forming committees for each plant that’s transitioning.
The heavier lift comes later: securing dedicated funding for affected communities, which would require approval from the Arizona Corporation Commission if regulated utilities like APS are expected to contribute.
Repowering isn’t a jobs guarantee
Utilities often point to “repowering” — converting coal units to natural gas — as a way to preserve employment. Ormond said two-thirds of the jobs from the coal plants will be lost when they repower to gas. “You need different skills and often different people,” she told ASU News.
That gap matters because the social fabric frays fast when high-paying jobs — like $100,000 or more — vanish. One worker often supports an entire family — grandparents, children, grandchildren — and the utility’s philanthropic funding on youth sports and civic events dries up alongside the payroll. Ormond said that even with a decade of notice, communities struggle to plan; denial is a powerful force, and early acceptance is rare.
Community Benefit Agreements for all development
The brief also pushes for Community Benefit Agreements — negotiated deals that require any new energy project, renewable or fossil, to pay into the community during and after its lifespan. Ormond argued the standard shouldn’t apply only to solar and wind. “We’ve got new pipelines going into Apache County and through Navajo County right now,” she said. “These pipelines should be paying community benefits as well as the clean, green stuff.”
The center’s approach is built on “co-creation” rather than top-down planning. Researchers hold visioning sessions in affected towns, helping residents identify what they want to maintain and what they want to grow, then supply technical capacity — feasibility studies for gas plants, battery recycling, or other options — that communities couldn’t do themselves.
Whether the policy recommendations get adopted as envisioned remains the open question. The structural fixes — an agency, the studies, the committees — can start without a vote. The money, as Ormond put it, “is really the most important part, probably,” and that will take leadership.