Baltimore Firefighters Sue City Over Unpaid Overtime After Missed Back-Pay Deadline

Baltimore firefighters filed a federal lawsuit Thursday after the city missed a September deadline to pay back overtime they say was withheld for more than a year.

Broken promise on back pay

Fire department general counsel Eilene Brown wrote to union attorneys Sept. 10 that payroll officials would correct the problem and issue retroactive payments within about six weeks, according to the complaint filed in U.S. District Court. As of the Nov. 19 filing, the 113 affected firefighters had received nothing, the lawsuit states.

The city also had not agreed to pay liquidated damages or attorneys’ fees the plaintiffs are seeking, the complaint adds. The Baltimore Mayor’s Office said it had not received any filings but would respond in court when it does; the fire department did not answer a request for comment, Hanford Sentinel reported.

Photo: new.patch.com

EMS assignment, firehouse schedule

A November 2024 policy requires fire academy graduates to serve 1,800 hours on emergency medical units before transferring to fire suppression. At least six academy classes have been placed in the program, the lawsuit says. During those assignments, firefighters were barred from working suppression shifts or taking suppression overtime. They worked two 10‑hour day shifts and two 14‑hour overnight shifts followed by four days off — a schedule averaging 42 hours a week — but were not paid time‑and‑a‑half for hours beyond 40.

Some received overtime only after 48 hours; others received none, the complaint alleges. The dispute turns on whether employees assigned exclusively to EMS qualify for the federal firefighter overtime exception, which allows a 53‑hour threshold.

Plaintiff Joseph Greely worked 96 hours in a two‑week pay period ending Aug. 12, 2025, and received no overtime for that period, his pay stub shows; he was paid his regular salary plus 96 cents an hour for working outside his classification.

Precedent from 1992

The lawsuit cites Nally v. Mayor and City Council of Baltimore, a 1992 federal ruling that rejected the city’s argument that certain EMS personnel qualified for the firefighter overtime exception. The plaintiffs contend the city is repeating the same misclassification more than three decades later.

Photo: arcamax.com

Five warnings before suit

International Association of Fire Fighters Local 734 first alerted fire department chiefs Jan. 30, then followed up Feb. 3, March 5, April 27 and Sept. 4, the complaint alleges. After the September meeting, Brown wrote that system changes were scheduled for Sept. 17 and that back pay would be issued in one lump sum with future payments corrected starting the Oct. 2 pay period.

None of that occurred, the lawsuit says. “This lawsuit is not simply about unpaid overtime,” the union said in a statement Thursday. “It is about accountability, fairness, and ensuring that the City follows the same federal labor laws that every other employer is expected to follow.”