The Big Ten Conference suspended nine players Saturday for a line brawl that erupted at the 12:54 mark of the third period Friday night at Yost Arena.
Four Michigan State players and five Michigan players received bans of one or two games, with supplemental discipline applied for leaving the bench or penalty box, the conference said. The league considers the matter concluded.
How the brawl started
The incident began when Spartans defenseman Sean Barnhill delivered a hit from behind on Wolverines forward Nick Moldenhauer, The Athletic reported. A subsequent shove on Michigan goaltender Jack Ivankovic touched off multiple fights. At least six players — three from each side — were ejected and 116 penalty minutes were assessed, according to The Athletic.
Michigan won the game 5-1, The Athletic reported. Moldenhauer left with an injury, as did Kason Muscutt, who had already been hurt earlier in the game. Michigan coach Brandon Naurato said both injuries “could be for a long time.”
Suspensions by player
The Big Ten announced the following supplemental discipline:
- Michigan State (four players, two games each): Sean Barnhill, Matthew Lahey and Shane Vansaghi — one game for a fighting game disqualification and one additional game for leaving the penalty box. Patrick Geary — one game for leaving the bench and one for fighting.
- Michigan (five players): Nic Sima, Adam Valentini and Jack Nesbitt — two games each. Sima received one game for a fighting disqualification and one for leaving the bench; Valentini and Nesbitt each received one game for leaving the bench and one for fighting. Aidan Park — one game for leaving the bench. Henry Mews — one game for head-butting an opponent.
Two other Wolverines, Drew Schock and Michael Hage, were initially given fighting majors and game disqualifications, but an NCAA review rescinded those penalties, clearing them to play Saturday, the conference said.
Schedule impact
The suspensions remove Barnhill, Lahey, Vansaghi and Geary from Saturday’s rematch at Michigan State and the Spartans’ Dec. 3 game at Ohio State. Sima, Valentini and Nesbitt will miss Saturday’s game and Michigan’s Nov. 27 contest against Ferris State. Park and Mews sit out Saturday only.
The Big Ten Conference, as the governing body for its 18 member institutions’ varsity hockey programs, issued the nine supplemental discipline rulings Saturday through the league office, distinguishing conference-level authority from the separate NCAA review that later rescinded fighting majors for Drew Schock and Michael Hage.
While the Big Ten imposed one- and two-game bans for leaving the bench or penalty box and fighting disqualifications, the NCAA’s independent process overturned the game disqualifications for two Wolverines, clearing them to play the next day and illustrating how conference supplemental discipline and national governing-body rulings operate on parallel tracks.
Coaches react
“We have a line brawl in Michigan-Michigan State. Started with a hit from behind from Sean Barnhill on Nick Moldenhauer. Multiple MSU players left the box to join in on it. Jack Nesbitt, Sean Barnhill and others ejected. There will be suspensions. Rare scene in college hockey.”, said Scott Wheeler on X, November 21, 2026.
“Their guy jumped the bench and came over towards ours. Anyone comes around Jack, it’s not good,” Naurato said after Friday’s game.
“(Barnhill) took a two-minute penalty and they didn’t like it, and that happens in hockey. You stick up for your teammate, and we’re going to stick up for our teammates. The refs did a great job of handling that,” Michigan State coach Adam Nightingale told the Lansing State Journal.
“It’s one of the biggest rivalries in sports, so there’s gonna be a lot of that. … If anyone goes after (Ivankovic), then it’s game on,” Nesbitt said.
Naurato’s message for Saturday: “Job’s not finished. Our goal this weekend wasn’t to win one game. So be good.”