“Five is too much. Take it down to three, we could live with it,” said Bob Johnson, a neighbor living directly in front of a proposed rental project on South Wilson Street.
The comment highlights a growing tension on the Boise Bench, where residents are now formally appealing city approvals for a five-cottage development.
While the city of Boise pushes to increase housing density through cottage villages, the Wilson Cottage Court project has become a flashpoint for local concerns.
Idaho News 6 Boise Twin Falls (KIVI) reported last week that the Planning and Zoning commission granted a conditional use permit and several variances for the half-acre site. The dispute isn’t necessarily about the existence of the homes, but rather the intensity of the development and how it interacts with the existing neighborhood infrastructure.
Irrigation Easement Forces Layout Variances
The developer, Land Architect, argues that the project’s layout is constrained by a 30-foot irrigation district easement running along the north side of the property. This restriction limits where driveways and parking can be placed, forcing the developer to seek variances for landscaping buffers and site setbacks.
Property owner Guy Skeele noted the difficulty of balancing municipal density goals with physical site limitations.
“We even tried to get more. Just so people can have storage, people have visitors, that sort of thing, so people don’t have to park on the street. But the property has restrictions on it,” Skeele told Idaho News 6 Boise Twin Falls (KIVI).
According to Idaho-Express, the project currently plans to exceed the city’s requirement of one parking space per cottage. However, neighbors argue that the technical compliance doesn’t account for the reality of a narrow, one-way dead-end street.
Residents Fear Worsening Driveway Turnarounds
The human stakes for residents involve daily travel on a street they feel is already over-taxed. Katherine Barker, who lives across from the property, said that existing traffic frequently turns around in private driveways, a situation she believes will worsen with additional units. “We have traffic turning around in our private driveways. It’s part of living on a dead end, but usually dead ends are designed in a way that accommodates smaller amounts of residential traffic,” Barker told Idaho News 6 Boise Twin Falls (KIVI).
Beyond traffic, the project has complicated relationships with immediate neighbors. One family relies on crossing a portion of the property to reach their garage, but the developer stated during the hearing that no recorded easement exists to guarantee that access. Efforts to reach a private agreement have not succeeded.
The Density Debate
The disagreement centers on the tension between city-wide housing needs and neighborhood-level capacity. Residents emphasize that their opposition is not a blanket rejection of new housing, noting that even their own family members struggle with the high cost of living in Boise.
| Concern | Resident Perspective | Developer/City Context |
|---|---|---|
| Density | Prefer a scale of three units rather than five. | Project meets or exceeds current city parking mandates. |
| Access | Concerns over private driveway usage and lack of recorded easements. | No recorded easement exists for the neighboring garage access. |
| Site Layout | Request for larger landscape buffers. | 30-foot irrigation easement limits buildable area. |
“We’re not opposed to housing at all. Actually, we have young adults that live at home because it’s too expensive to move out but it just doesn’t seem reasonable for the size of the property and the street that leads to it,” said neighbor Erin Scuglia.
With the appeal now moving forward, the project’s future rests on upcoming proceedings, potentially bringing the matter before the Boise City Council. For now, the developer maintains his commitment to the project, stating, “The best policy is always to find a way to get along with them. Always be the best neighbor you can.”
