Resistance-breaking root-knot nematode isolates have appeared across California tomato fields, challenging long-standing management tools used by growers.
Root-knot nematodes remain a major concern for tomato growers worldwide, with management relying heavily on the plant resistance gene Mi-1, which has been bred into most processing tomato cultivars. Repeated use of the Mi-1 gene has placed strong selection pressure on nematode populations, promoting the emergence of resistance-breaking isolates.
Despite the growing impact of resistance-breaking root-knot nematodes, their frequency, distribution, and species identity across California have remained poorly understood until now. In a study published in the Journal of nematology on February 1, 2023, researchers including AT Ploeg, CS Stoddard, and TA Turini isolated root-knot nematodes from processing tomato fields at 14 sites, identified them to species, and evaluated their reproduction on current rotation crops.
Of these resistance-breaking isolates, one was identified as M. javanica, and all others as M. incognita. Principal component analysis based on SNPs indicated significant genetic variation among several strains, implying that overcoming resistance developed separately across multiple fields rather than originating from a singular source population.
The USA is the largest producer of processing tomatoes, accounting for 34% of worldwide production. Approximately 95% of the US acreage is in California, representing a value of over $1 billion. Throughout the past five years, California’s harvested area has stayed relatively stable at 230,000 acres, yielding an average of 45 to 50 tons per acre, whereas yearly processing tomato crop damage within the state has been calculated at 10% to 20%.
To reduce nematode-induced harvest declines, producers chiefly apply soil fumigants like 1,3-dichloropropene, metam-potassium, and metam-sodium—which made up 19% of all pesticide active ingredients used on this crop in 2021—along with cultivating nematode-resistant varieties. Although the Mi-1 gene has been used for over 70 years as an effective management strategy, the frequency of resistance breaking appears to be increasing globally and domestically.
In greenhouse assays conducted by researchers from the Department of Nematology at the University of California Riverside, alongside UCCE personnel from Merced, Madera, Fresno, and Kern counties, alfalfa displayed the lowest reproduction of both wild-type and resistance-breaking M. incognita. Meanwhile, reproduction on other rotation crops varied by isolate.
Additional greenhouse pot trials evaluating sixteen Meloidogyne isolates multiplied on resistant tomato showed that pepper was resistant to all tested isolates and green bean to all M. incognita isolates. However, cotton and cowpea allowed reproduction of one of the resistance-breaking M. incognita isolates, and the resistant sweetpotato cultivar Bonita allowed reproduction of all five resistance-breaking isolates tested while stopping avirulent M. incognita.
These findings show that rotation decisions should be guided by local root-knot nematode population identity and host compatibility rather than generalized strategies across fields, as isolates overcoming resistance in tomato may also be virulent on resistant sweetpotato.