Carbon Brief Analysis Names Russia, Saudi Arabia, Australia as History’s Biggest CO2 Exporters

Carbon Brief analysis seen by The Guardian names Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia as the three largest exporters of carbon dioxide in history, placing the COP31 presidency under immediate scrutiny.

Since 1850, Russia has exported fossil fuels responsible for more than 70 gigatonnes of CO2, Saudi Arabia about 60 gigatonnes and Australia more than 25 gigatonnes, according to figures compiled by Robbie Andrew at the Norwegian climate institute CICERO.

The accounting method assigns emissions to the country where the coal, oil or gas is extracted, not where it is burned — a shift that more than doubles Australia’s historical contribution and quadruples Saudi Arabia’s, Carbon Brief reported.

The COP31 contradiction

The revelation lands as Australia co-presides over the UN climate summit in Turkey, now in its second week. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese told delegates last week that Australia was “doing its part,” yet Climate Analytics published separate analysis Tuesday showing the government continues to approve coal mines slated to operate until 2088 — decades past the mid-century net-zero target.

“It’s abundantly clear Australia is not ‘doing its part’ as the prime minister claimed here in Turkey last week,” said Bill Hare, chief executive of Climate Analytics. “There is a deep contradiction in a government position that champions climate ambition abroad but plans for continued fossil fuel exports, with approvals for coalmines and gasfields that lock in production for decades.”

Carbon Brief Analysis Names Russia, Saudi Arabia, Australia as History's Biggest CO2 Exporters
Photo: Carbon Brief

Louise Hutchins, convener of the Make Polluters Pay International Coalition, tied the export figures directly to the stalled finance talks. “Here at COP31, governments claim there’s not enough money to tackle the climate crisis, while Australia, Russia and Saudi Arabia, that have amassed fortunes from fossil fuels, continue to wield pivotal political power in this consensus-based process,” she told The Guardian.

“Just look at Australia. Its contribution to global heating more than doubles when fossil fuel exports are counted. Yet it is co-presiding over the very negotiations where climate finance talks are once again in stalemate.”

Negotiating positions harden

On Monday, Australia circulated a first draft cover decision calling for “the immediate transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems.” But several delegations said the language is unlikely to survive subsequent drafts.

Saudi Arabia, Russia and their allies in the Arab Group are opposing a cover text altogether, and the absence of the United States under Donald Trump has removed a key source of pressure for compromise, The Guardian reported.

Saudi Arabia’s energy ministry pushed back on the extraction-based accounting. A representative told The Guardian the kingdom accounts for roughly 1% of historical global CO2 emissions within its borders.

“Saudi Arabia exports oil to countries around the world to meet their energy needs. These countries decide how the oil is used, which technologies are employed, and how the resulting emissions are managed. It would therefore be misleading to place responsibility for those emissions on the exporting country while overlooking the role of those who consume the fuel,” the ministry said.

It added that Saudi crude ranks among the lowest in upstream carbon intensity, citing peer-reviewed research in Science and International Energy Agency data on methane intensity.

Australia and Russia were approached for comment but had not responded by publication.

Where the ledger shifts

Extraction-based accounting reshuffles the historical rankings. Russia remains the third-largest historical emitter even after adding its 69 billion tonnes of exported CO2, Carbon Brief found. The United Kingdom overtakes Germany to become the fourth-largest, while Saudi Arabia jumps to fifth.

Australia enters the top ten, more than doubling its share. Nations that fall down the list — Germany, India, France and COP31 host Turkey — are all heavy fossil-fuel importers. Japan, almost entirely dependent on imported fuels, is a particularly stark example, Carbon Brief reported.

The United States and China still bear greater total historical responsibility than the top three exporters because both burned large domestic reserves alongside imports.

Domestic politics constrain Canberra

Albanese faces a resurgent One Nation party at home that rejects net zero and denies climate science, complicating any pledge to phase out fossil-fuel exports that constitute roughly two-fifths of Australia’s export economy. Asad Rehman, chief executive of Friends of the Earth, framed the impasse as a structural deadlock.

“It’s time for the deadly tango between the producers of fossil fuels, and those locked into dependency on oil and gas, to have its last dance,” he told The Guardian.

“We must turn off the tap on fossil fuels and push richer nations to commit to a fair, fast and fully funded phaseout. That means real public finance, and access to the technology that can make it possible, for the countries bearing the brunt of climate breakdown.”

The COP28 outcome in Dubai called for a transition away from fossil fuels but set no timetable. With Saudi Arabia and Russia blocking even a cover text, and the US absent, delegates in Turkey expect several more drafts before the summit closes — if a cover decision survives at all.