Carson Benge finished second in the voting for the 2026 National League Rookie of the Year award, coming up short against Cincinnati Reds first baseman Sal Stewart as traditional statistics won over modern metrics.
According to the Baseball Writers’ Association of America, Stewart captured 20 of a possible 30 first-place votes and totaled 170 points in the balloting announced on November 10, 2026. Benge secured seven first-place votes to finish second with 107 points, while two voters placed him as low as fifth.
The voting exposed a clear philosophical split between traditional counting stats and advanced analytics. Stewart played in all 162 games, slugging 32 home runs and driving in 112 runs, numbers that QNS noted immediately overshadowed Benge’s 20 homers and 65 RBIs for the Flushing club.
The NL Rookie of the Year balloting pic.twitter.com/SRAD6CkoKH
Yet amNewYork pointed out that Benge held the advantage across several key categories, hitting .282 with 168 hits, 22 stolen bases, a .346 on-base percentage, and an 118 OPS+ compared to Stewart’s .263 average, 164 hits, 15 steals, .330 OBP, and 117 OPS+. Benge also became the first Mets rookie to record a 20-20 season, though a dismal April where he batted .189 dug an early hole in the race.
Beyond the batter’s box, the defensive metrics leaned heavily toward the Mets outfielder. Benge recorded a Fielding Run Value of 8, placed in the 85th percentile with a 96.6 mph arm strength, and led all National League right fielders with 10 outfield assists, while Stewart posted a minus-4 Fielding Run Value.

The runner-up finish carried hidden financial and organizational consequences for the franchise. Sports Illustrated said that because Benge did not win the award, President of Baseball Operations David Stearns missed out on acquiring a Prospect Promotion Incentive draft pick at the end of the first round, an asset that would have helped offset the team’s mandatory draft-slot drops triggered by exceeding the competitive balance tax.
Born in 2003, Carson Benge developed his two-way skills at Oklahoma State University before the Mets selected him in the first round of the 2024 MLB draft. He signed for $4 million and quickly rose through the minor leagues, earning recognition as the organization’s Minor League Player of the Year in 2025 before making his Major League debut in March 2026.
Benge ended his campaign with an .828 OPS over his final 126 games after holding just a .498 OPS on the morning of May 3.
Here's how Carson Benge and Sal Stewart stacked up in some of the analytical statistics this season pic.twitter.com/c8FyidNpfv