CBS Sports Grades 2025-26 Transfer Portal Hauls: St. John’s a, Kentucky D, UNC C

CBS Sports released its first report card on the 2026 college basketball transfer portal cycle on Thursday, grading the top ten hauls after the opening week of the season.

The analysis, penned by Matt Norlander, uses 247Sports’ algorithmic rankings to frame a simple tension: programs spent the spring building rosters that cost anywhere from $5 million to $25 million in NIL commitments, but the early returns suggest money alone doesn’t solve chemistry.

Dusty May proved a portal-heavy group can win a national title at Michigan last April, yet the first month of 2026-27 shows more friction than flow at the sport’s highest spenders.

St. John’s sets the standard

Rick Pitino’s squad sits 5-0 with an A grade, and the numbers back up the eye test. Tounde Yessoufou, a Baylor transfer, has essentially deleted the low-percentage shots that defined his 2025-26 season. He launched 46 pull-up threes for the Bears last year; through five games with the Johnnies, he has taken exactly one.

Playing off ex-EuroLeague point guard Quinn Ellis, Yessoufou is shooting 64 percent inside the arc and 44 percent from three. Keyshawn Hall, the other marquee addition, is guarding at a level Pitino hasn’t previously demanded of him. The early schedule softens the resume — next week’s Players Era Festival will clarify things — but the schematic fit is undeniable.

Kentucky’s defensive crisis

The wildest divergence belongs to Mark Pope’s Wildcats. Sitting 4-1 with a D grade, Kentucky ranks 261st nationally in defensive efficiency once preseason priors are stripped out, per CBS Sports. The portal strategy prioritized creators and shooters — Milan Momcilovic, one of the highest-paid players in the country, among them — but the frontcourt depth chart has collapsed.

Franck Kepnang and Justin McBride are outside the trust tree, leaving freshman Malachi Moreno as the lone reliable rim protector. Momcilovic has already gone public with frustration, telling reporters the Wildcats need to pressure the ball better to unlock their identity. “This ain’t Iowa State,” Norlander says, referencing the system Momcilovic left. One Moreno ankle roll, the report warns, and the season spirals.

CBS Sports Grades 2025-26 Transfer Portal Hauls: St. John's a, Kentucky D, UNC C
Photo: soz6.com

Isaiah Johnson validates Texas portal bet

Rodney Terry’s Longhorns earned the only other A in the top five. Colorado transfer Isaiah Johnson dropped 26 points on Baylor in San Antonio on November 15, validating the staff’s bet on a true lead guard.

Role players David Punch, Elyjah Freeman, and Amari Evans have all returned positive value. The schedule stiffens dramatically in December with Louisville, Miami, and Memphis on deck, but Texas has yet to regret a single portal move.

UNC’s injury nightmare

Hubert Davis’s Tar Heels (3-1, C-) watched their portal blueprint fracture in real time. The plan — Neo Avdalas as a jumbo creator, Terrence Brown for paint pressure, Matt Able for spacing — survived two scares against Western Carolina and Wyoming before Georgia walked into the Dean Dome and won 78-70 despite a nearly $10 million NIL disadvantage.

Then Avdalas suffered a wrist injury that will sideline him for months. Brown risks becoming a high-volume scorer on a losing team for a fourth season; Able now carries the burden of proving he can be a primary initiator.

Middle tier: Louisville’s guard logjam, Tennessee’s spacing trap

Pat Kelsey’s Cardinals (2-1, C+) blew an 18-point lead to Memphis, exposing a roster construction quirk: three combo guards — Jackson Shelstad, Seth Trimble, and returner Adrian Wooley — are sharing point guard duties without a true NBA-caliber facilitator among them. Alvaro Folgueiras might be the best passer on the team. Louisville’s ceiling depends on elite rebounding and defensive detail to mask the playmaking deficit.

Rick Barnes’s Volunteers (4-0, B+) evaporated Michigan State 61-46 in a defensive masterclass, yet the offensive architecture remains stubborn. Barnes’s two most-used lineups feature three non-shooters alongside guards Terrence Hill Jr. and Juke Harris. The result: 66-point slobber-knockers by design. Wake Forest transfer Harris is still working out of an early funk; until he and Hill hum simultaneously, Tennessee’s offense caps its own ceiling.

Gonzaga frontcourt depth creates luxury problem

Mark Few’s Zags (3-1, B) have a first-world frontcourt headache. Portal coup Massamba Diop flashes two-way menace at 7-foot-1, but backup Izan Almansa has earned more trust, potentially suppressing Diop’s counting stats. The guard rotation — Javon Bennett, Xaivian Lee, Isiah Harwell, Chauncey Wiggins — is deep if star-less; Harwell’s confidence after a lost freshman year at Houston stands out.

Jai Lucas’s Hurricanes (4-1, A-) have beaten only Florida among credible opponents. Acaden Lewis hasn’t shot well but creates at will; Somto Cyril looks transformed. The portal class — Nick Dorn, Brent Bland, Robert Miller — has delivered as advertised, though DeSean Goode is blocked by five-star Caleb Gaskins and Malik Reneau’s surprise return.

Mike Woodson’s Hoosiers (3-0, B+) beat Arkansas at Madison Square Garden behind a committee approach. Duke transfer Darren Harris (14.4 points, 36 percent from three) has been the steadiest hand; big men Samet Yigitoglu and Aiden Sherrell oscillate between rough and game-changing. Indiana projects as a tournament lock with second-weekend upside, though Big Ten contention remains unproven.

St. John’s, a founding member of the Big East, ranks ninth all-time with 1,973 Division I victories through the 2023–24 season. The program owns the most NIT appearances (27) and championships (six), though one title was later vacated.

Its 1910–11 team finished 14–0 and was retroactively honored as a national champion by the Helms Athletic Foundation. The Red Storm have reached 32 NCAA tournaments — most recently as 2026 Big East tournament champions — yet hold the record for the most appearances without winning the championship.

The portal economy, visualized

School Record Grade Primary Portal Concern
St. John’s 5-0 A Schedule strength ahead
Texas 4-0 A Upcoming SEC gauntlet
Miami 4-1 A- One quality opponent played
Indiana 3-0 B+ Big man consistency
Tennessee 4-0 B+ Self-imposed spacing limits
Gonzaga 3-1 B Frontcourt minutes crunch
Louisville 2-1 C+ No true point guard
UNC 3-1 C- Avdalas injury, defensive identity
Kentucky 4-1 D 261st defensive efficiency

The grades are early, the sample sizes tiny, and the portal rules still shifting beneath everyone’s feet. But the first month has already separated the rosters that were built to fit from the rosters that were merely built to spend.

Michigan’s 2026 title run proved the model works; Kentucky’s 261st-ranked defense proves it can backfire spectacularly when the pieces don’t defend. The next six weeks — conference play, tournament exemptions, injury luck — will decide which side of that line everyone else lands on.