Cedartown Police Officer Trenton Garner is back on full duty as of Monday, weeks after a district attorney cleared him of criminal wrongdoing in the shooting death of a donkey named HeeHaw, CBS News reported.
The reinstatement, effective immediately, was confirmed in a letter signed by Police Chief James Newsome and City Manager Edward Guzman. It closes the administrative chapter of an August 30 incident that began as a search for a missing 12-year-old girl and ended with a clash between body-camera footage, a prosecutor’s rationale, and a state agriculture department that saw a crime.
The night in the pasture
Shortly after midnight, Garner and other officers were combing a fenced pasture in Polk County. Body-camera video obtained by CBS News Atlanta shows a donkey galloping toward the officers as they back away. Garner told dispatch: “Firearm discharged at a donkey. It was trying to attack us in the pasture and on the track.”

In his incident report, Garner wrote that another officer activated a Taser’s electrical arc to scare the animal off. HeeHaw kept coming. Garner fired once. The donkey turned, moved uphill, and collapsed. The missing girl was later found safe at a nearby church.
Two investigations, opposite conclusions
The Georgia Department of Agriculture investigated and concluded Garner had violated criminal statutes. But on November 2, Tallapoosa Judicial Circuit District Attorney Jaeson Smith released a report rejecting charges. “After a review of Investigator Cruce’s entire investigation and all evidence, Garner’s actions do not sustain criminal liability,” Smith wrote.
Smith said the agriculture department’s assessment omitted important information. He cited the officer’s immediate sense of serious bodily harm and the reactions of a K-9 officer on scene.
Smith also pointed to past reports that HeeHaw had attacked people — including a neighbor’s account that the donkey bit a small child at a camp in July and would approach people “screaming and biting them.” The neighbor added the animal had been kept out of petting zoos since youth because it would jump on and bite people, Local News reported.
HeeHaw’s owner, Hannah Michelle Israel, described him differently: a sweet, bottle-fed baby donkey. She has sued Garner in federal court, alleging officers entered her fenced pasture without a warrant or permission and shot the animal without provocation. Garner has asked a judge to dismiss the case, invoking qualified immunity, CBS News reported.

The photo that became evidence
Smith added a detail that complicated the public narrative. He said a widely shared photo of the donkey after the shooting appeared to have been staged. The district attorney did not elaborate on what in the image suggested staging, but the claim undercut the visual that had circulated widely online.
Cedartown, the Polk County seat where the pasture shooting occurred, sits northwest of Atlanta near the Alabama line and had 10,190 residents in 2020. The town grew from a Cherokee village called Cedar Valley and was burned by Union forces under General Hugh Judson Kilpatrick in 1865 before being re-chartered in 1867.
Its Main Street and several districts are listed on the National Register of Historic Places, and the former Seaboard Air Line railbed now forms part of the Silver Comet Trail linking northwest Georgia cities.
Civil lawsuit continues with qualified immunity decision pending
The civil lawsuit remains active. A federal judge will decide whether qualified immunity shields Garner from damages. No hearing date has been set.