Chris Columbus Fired ‘Home Alone’ Actor After 4 Days: ‘He Was Awful

Chris Columbus revealed on Tuesday that he fired an actor from Home Alone after four days of filming, the only dismissal in his directing career, cleveland.com reported.

The director told the Wildmen podcast that the studio refused to pay for Daniel Stern, his first choice to play Marv opposite Joe Pesci. “We didn’t have Dan Stern because the studio wouldn’t pay for Dan Stern,” Columbus said. “I conceived of Dan Stern and Joe Pesci in this movie as the bad guys. And they said, ‘You only get one.’ So I said, ‘Okay, let’s go with Pesci.’”

The studio cast another actor instead, but a screen test with Pesci proved disastrous. “We did a screen test and they were horrible,” Columbus said. “I mean, Pesci was great. This other kid was, and he was a kid at the time, he was just awful. And I had to— that’s the only person I ever had to fire.”

Columbus did not name the actor, but Daniel Roebuck identified himself as the fired performer on the What a Character! podcast in 2023. Roebuck disputed Columbus’s account, saying he was never intended to stay in the role. “I was never gonna be Marv,” Roebuck said. “Now that’s the one thing they never say. I was never ever going to film as Marv.”

He described a dismissive handshake from writer-producer John Hughes: “I got the wettest handshake of my life with John Hughes. It was the most disappointing handshake I ever received because I was a fan of the guy. And he clearly didn’t want me to be there. It was all so obvious.”

Chris Columbus Fired 'Home Alone' Actor After 4 Days: 'He Was Awful
Photo: yahoo.com

The studio’s budget decision reshaped the villain duo

Columbus explained that 20th Century Fox limited him to one established actor for the burglars. He chose Pesci, leaving Marv to a less experienced performer. The chemistry vacuum was immediate. “We did a screen test and they were horrible,” Columbus repeated on the podcast. The failure forced the production to halt filming with the original Marv after just four days.

Stern eventually took the part, creating the comic partnership that anchored the film’s slapstick violence. Columbus called the firing “the only person I ever had to fire” in a career spanning The Goonies, Mrs. Doubtfire, and the first two Harry Potter films.

Roebuck says promised role never came

Roebuck recalled Columbus softening the blow with a pledge: “Chris Columbus said I will give you a great part of my next movie.” Decades later, Roebuck noted the promise went unfulfilled. “Now, I notice he’s done 20 since then and he’s never called. But what really was disappointing was, you know, no one ever just told me the truth.” Entertainment Weekly reached out to Roebuck’s representative for comment.

Columbus and Roebuck differ on firing intent

The discrepancy between Columbus’s and Roebuck’s versions centers on intent. Columbus frames the firing as a performance rescue; Roebuck frames it as a predetermined swap. Both agree on the timeline: four days of filming, then Stern’s arrival. The film became a massive worldwide hit on a modest budget, making the casting pivot one of the most consequential in comedy history.

Columbus, 68, shared the story on the Tuesday episode of Wildmen. Roebuck’s 2023 podcast appearance resurfaced this week alongside the director’s remarks.