Variety caught Chris Columbus 20 minutes before the embargo lifted on a new Home Alone movie, and the director of the 1990 original told them a sequel without Catherine O’Hara “can’t happen.”
O’Hara, who played Kevin McCallister’s mother Kate, died January 30 at 71. “Catherine, as I’ve always said, is 50% of Home Alone,” Columbus said. “There’s the yin and yang of Home Alone: Catherine O’Hara and Macaulay Culkin. Without those two in the film, there is no film, because they create the emotional epicenter of that film.”
Disney announced Friday that Culkin will reprise the role in a legacy sequel written and produced by Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg through their Point Grey banner; the project grew from a pitch Culkin made to Disney film chief David Greenbaum, told from the perspective of an older Kevin endangering his own children, Deadline reported.
Columbus argued the franchise’s previous attempts failed because filmmakers “don’t understand why that cast works so well. It’s always about the cast. It’s like The Goonies. It’s about the cast.” John Heard died in 2017. Joe Pesci rarely acts for anyone other than Martin Scorsese and Pete Davidson. “Let’s not downsize Harry and Marv,” Columbus said.
“Daniel Stern and Joe Pesci are the ultimate comic duo for that particular film. Everyone has tried in subsequent sequels to be as funny or as interesting as Dan and Joe, and they just had a chemistry that is undefinable. So you can’t do that.”
Columbus praised Culkin’s November 17 McDonald’s holiday commercial — “Macaulay is a great actor, and I hope to work with him on something. Maybe it’ll be Home Alone-related, maybe it won’t” — and said he could still imagine a reunion built around the original ensemble.
“I think you potentially could still entertain the idea of doing another Home Alone with the cast. Not any of these ridiculous follow-ups to the first.” When Variety followed up after the announcement, Columbus declined to comment further.
Columbus wrote the screenplays for Gremlins and The Goonies in the mid-1980s before making his directorial debut with Adventures in Babysitting (1987).
He later directed the first two Harry Potter adaptations, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone (2001) and Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets (2002), and served as a producer on The Help (2011), which earned him an Academy Award nomination for Best Picture. Born in Spangler, Pennsylvania, in 1958, he studied film at New York University’s Tisch School of the Arts.
The franchise continued without Culkin and Columbus in Home Alone 3 (1997), Home Alone 4 (2002), Home Alone: The Holiday Heist (2012) and Disney+’s Home Sweet Home Alone (2021). In 2020 Columbus called the planned reboot “a waste of time” and said “nobody got in touch with me about it.” Last year he told Entertainment Tonight another Home Alone would be a “mistake.”
Rogen has his own tie to O’Hara: she played studio executive Patty Leigh in his Apple TV+ comedy The Studio, a role she still held when she died. O’Hara also spoke at Culkin’s Walk of Fame ceremony in December 2023. Columbus is next set to direct Gremlins 3, scheduled to begin shooting early next year, and executive produced Robert Eggers’ horror film Werwulf, which Focus Features opens December 25.