Burlington Deputy Police Chief Jon Young will become Montpelier’s next police chief on Jan. 4, 2027, the city announced Monday.
Young, 52, of Milton, emerged from a national pool of 16 applicants, including four from Vermont, to lead a department authorized for 17 sworn officers and 10 emergency communication dispatchers. The hire concludes a three-month search managed by JW Consulting, the firm run by former Vermont State Police Director James W. Baker, at a cost of roughly $33,500.
“My goals are always to leave people feeling safer, calmer, and more valued after every interaction with the police.”
Jon Young, incoming Montpelier Police Chief, in a city statement
The vacancy opened in May when former Chief Eric Nordenson left after roughly three years to lead the Northfield Police Department. His departure triggered an exodus: Deputy Chief Kevin Moulton, Sgt. Diane Mathews, and Detective Alesha Donovan followed him to Northfield, which is now at its full complement of six officers. Detective Sgt. Jeffrey Pearson, a 17-year veteran, has served as interim chief since July 6.

Young inherits a department currently carrying 13 officers, including two recent hires still in field training, McNicholas Kury told The Bridge. The city’s recruitment brochure lists the salary range at $130,000 to $150,000; Young told the Times Argus on Monday that his compensation is still being negotiated.
Young’s resume spans 26 years in law enforcement, with more than two decades at the Burlington Police Department. He started there in August 1998 after 2½ years with the Rockport, Maine, Police Department. He worked patrol and detectives, served as a field supervisor and watch commander, and spent two years on a U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration task force in Vermont.
He left Burlington for a three-year stint as a Federal Air Marshal with the Transportation Security Administration’s Boston Field Office. After retiring from Burlington in 2021, he managed field services for Vermont Gas Systems in South Burlington until Interim Burlington Chief Shawn Burke recruited him back as a deputy chief in June 2025 to address a supervisory shortage.
Young also teaches criminal justice as an adjunct professor at Champlain College, where he earned an associate degree, a bachelor’s in business administration from the University of Phoenix, and a master’s in executive leadership. He served six years in the U.S. Marine Corps Reserves.
The capital city faces many of the same systemic pressures Young dealt with in Burlington: homelessness, mental health crises, and addiction. McNicholas Kury told The Bridge that strengthening alternative response programs, creating accountability pathways, and diverting people from incarceration are top priorities.
Young acknowledged the overlap.
The search process leaned heavily on community input. A separate law-enforcement panel drew from the Capital Police, Vermont State Police, and Montpelier Police.
Repeated attempts to reach McNicholas Kury at her city office Monday were unsuccessful; the voicemail indicated the mailbox was full and she did not respond to email.