Portland’s Westside Express Service carried an average of 13 passengers per railcar in 2025, a figure so low that the taxpayer subsidy for each round-trip commuter approached $48,000 a year — enough to buy a new Tesla Model 3 or similar electric car.
The numbers come from a new analysis by Randal O’Toole, an adjunct scholar at the Cascade Policy Institute, who argues it is time to “pull the plug” on the 14-mile line connecting Beaverton, Tigard, Tualatin, and Wilsonville. Oklahoma Council of Public Affairs reported the findings as Oklahoma City officials advance a $1.8 billion proposal for an Edmond–Oklahoma City–Norman commuter rail.
When WES was first proposed in 2004, officials predicted it would provide 3,000 trips each weekday. The system never hit that mark. Peak ridership reached 2,031 in 2014 and fell to 1,490 by 2019. The pandemic crushed it further; by 2025, weekday trips stood at 488 — roughly 244 unique riders making round trips, according to O’Toole’s calculation.
New article: Nearly $95 in taxpayer subsidies. Per ride. That's what TriMet's WES commuter rail required in 2025. With low ridership and high costs, could buses serve the Beaverton-Wilsonville route for less? Cascade's Randal O'Toole examines the numbers.… pic.twitter.com/2OwXFrCv0A
“The train is a huge money sink—costing taxpayers almost $95 for every one of the few people who ride it—and hardly anyone uses it.”
O’Toole wrote.
Fare revenue has evaporated. Since 2021, taxpayers have covered more than 99 percent of operating costs. In 2025, riders paid an average of 62 cents per trip while the public subsidy ran nearly $95 per ride. A daily round-trip commuter therefore receives an annual subsidy of almost $48,000.
O’Toole contends that a 40-seat electric bus could handle the actual passenger load at a fraction of the cost. He urges Portland to shut down WES and redirect funding to expanded bus service.
Oklahoma City’s proposed 35-mile line would link Edmond, downtown Oklahoma City, and Norman at an estimated $1.8 billion. Backers say it will serve suburban workers headed to the urban core. But downtown Oklahoma City now ranks among the five highest office-vacancy rates out of 92 U.S. markets, a shift mirrored in Minneapolis, where a similar commuter-rail service ceased operations this year after work-from-home trends gutted ridership.
Mayor David Holt, a proponent of the new line, dismissed financial concerns about the existing OKC Streetcar, which recently eliminated fares of 50 cents to $3 to attract riders.
“In government, we don’t measure the success of our services by the profit they turn.”
Holt wrote, “because they never have and they never will.”
The two systems differ in scale, geography, and funding structure. Portland’s experience cannot predict Oklahoma City’s ridership. But WES illustrates the financial consequence when projections miss wildly and fixed-rail infrastructure is left carrying handfuls of passengers at a cost that could literally put them in new electric cars.