City of Fargo Asks Judge to Dismiss Angela Lipps’ $10M Lawsuit

Fargo fights $10M facial recognition lawsuit

Ten million dollars rests on whether a Tennessee woman’s arrest at gunpoint, triggered by a facial recognition match, crossed constitutional lines or remained a protected police mistake.

The City of Fargo and Lucas Heck are fighting back against a high-stakes federal lawsuit, asking a judge to throw out the case entirely according to a court filing submitted on Monday. Angela Lipps filed the civil complaint in U.S. District Court in North Dakota on Sept. 15, 2025, after spending months entangled in a multi-state legal nightmare.

The court action reveals that the city and Heck deny any violation of civil rights or the existence of unconstitutional department policies. They want the lawsuit dismissed with prejudice, meaning Lipps cannot refile it, while demanding a jury trial and seeking to recover their own legal costs and attorneys’ fees.

The case exposes the mechanics of modern automated policing. Heck, who was a Fargo police detective at the time, was investigating a string of Fargo-area bank fraud incidents when a West Fargo police analyst supplied him with facial recognition data pointing toward Lipps, a resident of Elizabethton, Tennessee. Heck subsequently submitted a report to prosecutors recommending charges and an affidavit of probable cause, leading to a nationwide warrant.

Lipps was arrested at gunpoint July 14, 2025, at a neighbor’s home. Because she was already on probation in Tennessee, the North Dakota felony charges served as a separate basis for alleged probation violations.

While those matters were pending, she remained incarcerated in Tennessee, settled on a failure-to-report violation exclusively in September, and traveled by plane to North Dakota in October. She made her first appearance in North Dakota on Oct. 31, and a judge set a $100,000 bond she couldn’t pay, according to the complaint.

She remained in the Cass County Jail until Dec. 24, 2025. Prosecutors dismissed the charges after she produced bank records she says show she was in Tennessee during the thefts.

What the city admits and denies

The legal defense acknowledges several foundational facts. The city admits Heck received the facial recognition lead from West Fargo, used it to secure a warrant, and later participated in an interview with Lipps and her attorney where she denied involvement and asked to see the surveillance footage.

Crucially, the court filing admits the Fargo Police Department did not own its own facial recognition software at the time. The department maintained no formal written policy specifically governing the technology and provided no internal training on it, though investigators consulted with other agencies, the practice was to use results alongside other techniques, and they did not rely on them alone.

However, the city flatly denies all five claims in the lawsuit, which include unlawful seizure and arrest, due process violations, municipal liability over policies and training, false arrest and imprisonment, and malicious prosecution. The defense also rejects allegations that Heck presented the software match as a positive identification or that he completely stopped investigating once he received the lead.

Thirteen additional defenses support the city’s position, including qualified immunity, good faith execution of duties, and arguments that Lipps failed to mitigate her own damages. The filing asserts that if any fault exists, it belongs to Lipps or other outside parties.

Fargo police implement new facial recognition policies after investigative errors

The fallout from the arrest extends beyond the courtroom. Then-Fargo Police Chief Dave Zibolski acknowledged at a March news conference that the department made “investigative errors” and subsequently instituted new facial recognition policies and training.

Reference to that press briefing appears in the complaint, which notes that Zibolski additionally stated the probe’s reliance on West Fargo’s facial recognition outcomes presented a problem and that the technology ought not to have been utilized. The city’s new court filing argues that those statements speak for themselves, even as it defends the overall propriety of the detention.

Lipps alleges she was released from jail with four cents to her name and without an adequate winter coat. The city responds that it lacks enough information to answer many of those specific post-release details, leaving a federal judge to sort out accountability.