CNBC: Apparel Prices Hit Record Highs as Shoppers Reject Synthetics

“If it’s not a natural material, a retailer brand who passes it off as it is, they’re really becoming very low on consumers’ minds,” said Sonia Lapinsky, head of fashion at AlixPartners, speaking to CNBC.

The consulting firm’s 2026 Consumer Sentiment Index, surveying more than 9,000 shoppers, confirms a structural break: buyers are scrutinizing fiber content labels and rejecting premium-priced synthetics.

The Bottom Line:

  • Cotton’s share of U.S. apparel imports has fallen from 60% in 2010 to roughly 45% today, while polyester and nylon now dominate the import mix.
  • Import prices for cotton-heavy garments hit $3.67 per square meter in the first eight months of 2026, a 21% rise since 2010; synthetics averaged $2.64, up 11% over the same span.
  • Ralph Lauren shares have surged 85% in two years as its 90% natural-fiber assortment drives full-price sell-through.

The Polyester Pivot Has a Price Tag

For two decades, the CPI for apparel drifted lower. Fast fashion — Forever 21, H&M, then Shein and Fashion Nova — flooded the zone with petroleum-based fabrics that cost pennies per yard. That era ended in 2020.

Since then, apparel prices have soared to record highs even as the fiber mix kept skewing synthetic. CNBC reported that the average landed cost of predominantly synthetic imports reached $2.64 per square meter between January and August, versus $3.67 for cotton-dominant goods.

The spread matters. Cotton import costs have climbed 21% since 2010; synthetics only 11%. Yet retailers have been marking up both categories aggressively.

“If you’re appealing to a more value-sensitive customer, you either reduce the quality, or you negotiate with suppliers to try to share some of the cost or you maybe absorb the cost … and perhaps hope to crank a higher volume of product to make up for it,” said Aneesha Sherman, senior retail analyst at Bernstein Research.

CNBC: Apparel Prices Hit Record Highs as Shoppers Reject Synthetics
Photo: exponews.com

Athleisure Masked a Quality Trade-Down

Euromonitor data cited by Sherman shows U.S. sports apparel grew at a 4.9% annual clip from 2015 to 2025, more than double the 2.6% pace for total apparel and footwear. Polyester’s technical virtues — stretch, wicking, shape retention — made it the default for that boom. “There probably is some quality trade down as well happening there. But I think both these trends are conflated,” Sherman told CNBC.

Gen Z has turned the word “polyester” into a pejorative for anything cheap or fake.

Supply-Chain Shuffling Eroded Craft

“If you have to mark down that product because the consumer doesn’t want it as much, your net margin might actually be worse than if you were to just invest in quality in the first place,” said Janine Stichter, consumer analyst at BTIG.

Tariffs and Oil Shock the Synthetic Model

Petroleum-based fibers track crude. The Iran war sent oil prices skyrocketing, narrowing the cost gap between polyester and cotton. Consumer Edge data shows Shein’s year-over-year share of U.S. card spending fell in Q4 2025 and the first two quarters of 2026.

Zara’s sentiment also dipped three spots in the AlixPartners index, though sales and profits kept growing. “What we found over the years with this consumer sentiment index is that sometimes it will be a bit of a leading indicator of what’s to come,” Lapinsky said.

“I’m not saying that this is going to be true for Zara, but I think that’s one thing that we’ll be watching as we look in the upcoming quarters and into 2027.”

Natural-Fiber Portfolios Win the Pricing Power Test

Ralph Lauren's fiscal 2026 results show the divergence: more full-price sales, fewer markdowns, and a stock up 85% in two years. Roughly 90% of its apparel uses cotton, leather, wool, viscose, cashmere or silk, per its 2026 sustainability report.

AlixPartners, founded in 1981 by Jay Alix in Southfield, Michigan, pioneered consulting for companies in or near bankruptcy and first gained public recognition in 1984 by uncovering $100 million for DeLorean Motor Co. creditors. The firm has since advised on some of the largest Chapter 11 reorganizations, including General Motors, Kmart, and Enron, and grew to a staff of over 1,000 with offices in more than 20 cities worldwide.

Synthetic Costs May Drive Shift to Natural Fibers

Stichter believes rising synthetic input costs could accelerate a reversion to natural fibers. The AlixPartners survey signals the consumer is already there — willing to pay more, but only if the label justifies it. Shein did not immediately respond to a request for comment.