Columbia Falls residents pushed back hard Monday against a proposed short-term rental permit renewal fee that would jump more than fivefold, from $40 to $250 a year, telling the City Council the increase threatens the “mom and pop” operators who make up the bulk of the local market.
The fee structure, unveiled earlier this month, is the financial engine behind a new enforcement program designed to close a compliance gap that has left an estimated $150,000 to $250,000 in resort taxes uncollected over the last four years. City Manager Eric Hanks told the council the fees are calibrated to cover administrative costs — roughly $68,000 annually for software and a dedicated compliance officer — not to generate profit.
“You raise my costs, I’m going to raise my rents, and am I going to operate at a loss? No. At some point, I’m just going to say I’ve had enough of this, and I’m going to move on,”
Schleusner warned the council that the burden falls disproportionately on local owners. Of the roughly 150 short-term rentals the city has identified, 87 hold active licenses, and the vast majority of owners list Montana addresses, according to figures presented to the council. Only 44 owners are based out of state, with California and Texas accounting for five apiece.

The compliance gap driving the policy
Columbia Falls has been drafting the rules for about a year, spurred by the Montana Land Use Planning Act’s new requirements. The council explicitly rejected zoning-based caps on where rentals can operate, opting instead for a uniform permitting system that applies citywide regardless of zone.
Under the draft resolution, every operator would need an annual Special Provisions Permit verified against property ownership records. The city has contracted third-party monitoring software — costing about $8,500 a year — to scrape listing platforms like Airbnb and Vrbo, cross-reference permit status, and flag resort tax delinquencies. Hanks said the data shows most non-compliance isn’t accidental.
“Most of the people that aren’t paying resort tax, majority have come in to talk to us at some point, and then have failed to provide all the information, or they start paying resort tax and they stop paying resort tax,”
Life safety and the “cost of doing business”
Councilor John Piper framed the fee as a consumer protection issue as much as a revenue one. He said that without a valid permit and the required fire and health inspections, an owner’s liability exposure in the event of a guest injury becomes severe.
The policy also mandates property-specific guest rules — occupancy limits tied to parking capacity, quiet hours, bear-aware trash protocols, and a local contact capable of reaching the property within 60 minutes.
“Part of compliance to me is the life safety issue; that’s huge. It’s also a protection for folks that are doing this. If something happens to somebody staying there, at the VRBO or whatever, and you’re not under compliance, it’s going to be very costly to you,”
Developers like Mick Ruis, who holds roughly 20 short-term rental units downtown, would face the same per-unit fee structure: $400 for an initial permit, $250 for renewal, and $100 for each additional unit on a parcel, plus fire inspection costs. The city estimates the new fee schedule would generate about $40,750 annually — still leaving a roughly $27,000 shortfall against the $68,000 program cost.
Columbia Falls, incorporated in 1909 along the Flathead River in Flathead County, grew from a 1891 settlement anticipating the Great Northern Railway. The city of 5,308 residents sits 17 miles from Glacier National Park and a mile from Flathead National Forest. For decades its economy centered on the Anaconda Aluminum Co. reduction plant, built in the mid-1950s downstream of Hungry Horse Dam, and the Montana Veterans Home, serving veterans since 1896.
Council directs staff to explore lower renewal rate for compliant operators
The council directed staff to explore a lower renewal rate for operators with a clean compliance history, though several members acknowledged the “cost is the cost” of running a credible enforcement program. A final draft incorporating public comment and council revisions is scheduled for presentation and a vote on December 7. If adopted, the new program takes effect January 1, 2027.