A Colorado Court of Appeals panel on Thursday threw out state wildlife area rules after finding Colorado Parks and Wildlife failed to consider nearly 200 public comments submitted through its own website.
The decision reverses a district court ruling that had upheld the 2023 regulations, which restricted access for wildlife viewers while allowing hunters and anglers in the same areas. The three-judge panel ruled the agency violated the state Administrative Procedure Act by soliciting comments on its “Engage CPW” platform but never presenting them to the decision-makers who finalized the rules.
“Colorado Parks and Wildlife invited the public to submit comments to its proposed state wildlife area rules on its online platform. Nearly 200 people did so,” the opinion said, according to Colorado Expres. “But the agency concedes that those comments were never presented to or considered by the agency decision-makers who promulgated the final rules.”

The lawsuit was filed by Friends of Animals, River Runners for Wilderness, and Living River. Their attorney, Stephen Hernick, said the groups were concerned the regulations “really discriminated against people who wanted to observe wildlife but not hunt and fish in state wildlife areas.”
“We had assumed that CPW had considered all public comments submitted,” Hernick said. “We were frankly pretty stunned when CPW’s attorneys told us. ‘Actually, no, CPW didn’t consider any of these comments that were submitted to Engage CPW.'”
In April 2023, the agency opened a six-week comment period on the proposed changes. It received 191 comments through the website and seven emails, according to Colorado Public Radio. The court’s opinion noted CPW estimated about a quarter of the online commenters supported the proposal, while many opposed provisions allowing hunting dogs in areas where personal pets were banned.

Commenters also objected to the exclusion of non-motorized boaters. “You should allow non-motorized boaters to use these areas for access to recreational boating,” one wrote. “Using these areas for out-ins and take-outs does not interfere with fishing or hunting. You should not exclude user groups in this way.”
Another from Carbondale wrote: “I live in Carbondale and feel that it is unfair to only allow fishing/hunting on the Roaring for rivers. The stretch of the Roaring Fork River from Aspen to Glenwood Spring should be allowed to all, not just hunters and fishermen.”
Colorado Parks and Wildlife manages the state parks system, wildlife areas and the Colorado Natural Areas Program, with roots tracing to a 1937 legislative land board that created the first State Parks Board. The modern agency formed in 2011 when Colorado State Parks and the Colorado Division of Wildlife merged, and by 2017 it oversaw 42 state parks and 307 wildlife areas.
An eleven-member commission appointed by the governor sets policy, and voters have directed major wildlife decisions at the ballot box, including a 2020 measure requiring the commission to develop a plan to restore gray wolves by the end of 2023.
Hernick criticized the agency’s response to the oversight. “The disappointing thing for us was that CPW didn’t recognize this error, didn’t recognize that, ‘Oh there was, there was clearly some confusion here that we caused by encouraging people to submit comments to Engage CPW,'” he said.
The ruling was reported Thursday by Law360, which noted the panel found the agency used a communication method for public comment not mentioned in the official notice of rulemaking.