Colorado Environmental Groups Urge Congress to Reject Permitting Bill as Hickenlooper, Bennet Split

Colorado environmental advocates gathered at Denver’s Confluence Park Wednesday to urge Congress to reject a sweeping federal permitting overhaul that has fractured the Democratic caucus and pitted the state’s two senators against each other.

The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, or BAAJA, has become the lame-duck Republican Congress’s top energy priority after years of stalled negotiations over how to speed approvals for major infrastructure.

Trade groups representing fossil fuel and pipeline companies have lobbied aggressively for the bill, yet it also carries the endorsement of some influential climate advocates who argue it will accelerate the transmission lines and renewables buildout essential to the energy transition.

“BAAJA would send us backwards,” Ellie Andrews of Environment Colorado told reporters at the press conference. “It may help some renewable energy projects move forward, but it accelerates mining, it accelerates drilling, it will accelerate building pipelines.”

She called the legislation a “Trojan horse” that would undermine bedrock environmental laws — the National Environmental Policy Act, the Clean Water Act, and the Endangered Species Act — that have protected land, air, and water for more than 50 years.

Colorado Environmental Groups Urge Congress to Reject Permitting Bill as Hickenlooper, Bennet Split
Photo: yahoo.com

“This bill is not the way forward to a clean energy future. It’s a destructive path that will cause irreversible harm to our public lands and the communities that depend on them,” said Taylor Luneau, Colorado conservation manager for The Wilderness Society. “We’re grateful to Sen. Bennet for opposing this bill, and we urge Sen. Hickenlooper to do the same.”

The split in Colorado’s delegation mirrors the national divide. Sen. John Hickenlooper has cast multiple votes to advance the measure this month, while Sen. Michael Bennet has held firm in opposition. In a Nov. 9 statement, Bennet said he was “concerned that not all perspectives were sufficiently heard during the drafting of this far-reaching piece of legislation.”

Hickenlooper, in his own statement earlier this month, acknowledged the bill “isn’t perfect” but called it a “golden opportunity to make good on our promise to voters to make energy more affordable.”

The legislation was negotiated by four committee leaders: Republicans Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia and Mike Lee of Utah, and Democrats Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island and Martin Heinrich of New Mexico. On Wednesday, the measure cleared several more procedural votes with a bloc of roughly 15 to 20 Democrats, including Hickenlooper, continuing to vote yes.

Opponents’ central worry is a “project certainty” provision that would curtail the power of federal agencies and courts to revoke or modify approvals once granted.

Supporters frame the change as insurance against wholesale reversals when administrations change — pointing to former President Joe Biden’s cancellation of the Keystone XL pipeline in 2021 and President Donald Trump’s cancellation of offshore wind projects. Environmental groups counter that the provision could “lock in” major fossil fuel projects at a moment when climate scientists say the opposite is needed.

“To stop a project because somebody discovered something, that no doubt is frustrating,” Andrews said. “But the things that get discovered matter, and there’s a process for that, and it’s been hammered out over 50-odd years.”

A coalition of nearly thirty Colorado environmental and conservation organizations — including Wilderness Workshop, the Western Colorado Alliance, and the Western Watersheds Project — warns the bill would accelerate data-center development and further enable rapid expansion of Immigration and Customs Enforcement detention capacity envisioned by architects of Trump’s mass-deportation program. Tribal groups have faulted the narrowing of consultation requirements and protections for sacred and cultural sites.

For Colorado specifically, the groups argue that fast-tracking energy development carries profound implications for Western Slope ecosystems and open ranges. Expedited approvals could fragment critical winter ranges and migration corridors relied on by mule deer, elk, and pronghorn, while further threatening fragile greater sage-grouse populations.

They also point to ongoing air-quality violations across the Front Range, warning that fast-tracking fossil fuel infrastructure risks exacerbating ground-level ozone and toxic emissions in communities already struggling to meet federal clean-air benchmarks.

Proponents, including congressional sponsors and utility developers, maintain that restructuring approval processes is necessary to modernize the electric grid and meet surging power demand. Clean energy developers have similarly pointed out that lengthy bureaucratic reviews frequently stall vital interstate transmission corridors and renewable generation needed to transition away from coal.

Opponents see it differently. “The midterms sent a pretty clear message,” Andrews said. “I think there is definitely hope in the future for a stronger political coalition that can keep more of those voices at the table.” The bill could see further amendments before final Senate passage this week, after which it would need House approval before heading to Trump’s desk.