Colts Beat Dolphins as Daniel Jones Posts Worst QBR This Season

Indianapolis Colts quarterback Daniel Jones posted a 1.7 QBR on Sunday, the worst mark by any starter this season, yet the team escaped with a 24-22 win over the one-win Miami Dolphins.

The Colts snapped a five-game losing streak only because Miami missed two field goals and failed a two-point conversion in the final minutes. Indianapolis managed merely 10 offensive points through 59 minutes; the other 10 came on a defensive touchdown and a field goal.

“I don’t think it was my best,” Jones said after finishing 11-of-22 for 108 yards with one touchdown and two interceptions, including a 59-yard pick-six by Dolphins rookie cornerback Chris Johnson. “Obviously, I gotta do a better job taking care of the ball.”

Miami Dolphins vs Indianapolis Colts Game Highlights — NFL

Jones leads the NFL with 15 turnovers — 12 interceptions and three lost fumbles — through 10 games. His 12 picks are tied for the league high and match his career-worst total with seven games remaining. For most franchises, that production would force a quarterback change. Coach Shane Steichen insists it will not.

“I think we need to continue to get better,” Steichen said Sunday when pressed on the benching question. “There’s a lot of things that happened out there Sunday.”

The Colts sit 3-7 with a Thursday night date against the Houston Texans. Steichen confirmed Jones will start on the short week, effectively closing the door on Anthony Richardson Sr. or sixth-round rookie Riley Leonard for now. That decision has reignited a debate about unequal standards at the position.

Richardson, the fourth overall pick in 2023, was benched in October 2024 after voluntarily leaving a game against Houston because of fatigue. Steichen flipped between Richardson and veteran Joe Flacco twice that season, framing each move as developmental. Jones, signed to a two-year, $88 million contract in March, has received no such public ultimatum despite a longer track record of failure.

Colts Beat Dolphins as Daniel Jones Posts Worst QBR This Season
Photo: sports.yahoo.com

“The problem isn’t that Steichen expected more from Richardson. That’s part of being an NFL head coach,” the column argued. “The problem is that those expectations haven’t been consistent.”

The disconnect extends beyond the quarterback. Against a Dolphins defense allowing nearly 60 receiving yards per game to tight ends, second-year weapon Tyler Warren saw three targets — his first catch arriving in the fourth quarter. Warren finished with two receptions for one yard.

“Three targets for the most talented receiving option currently available to Indianapolis is extremely difficult to defend.” The outlet compared the desired usage to Arizona’s deployment of Trey McBride: 8-10 targets built on short routes, screens, motion and occasional Wildcat snaps.

Meanwhile, the backfield produced 160 yards on 28 carries (5.7 per rush). Jonathan Taylor averaged 5.2 yards on 16 attempts; rookie Seth McGowan ripped off 6.4 yards on 12 carries. Yet Taylor commanded just 57 percent of the running-back carries and 68 percent of offensive snaps.

“If the organization believes Taylor is valuable enough to keep around during a rebuilding season, why isn’t it treating him like the centerpiece of its offense?” The Colts reportedly turned down second-round offers for Taylor at the deadline, valuing him at a first-rounder. If health preservation is the goal, the outlet argued, shut him down. If winning is the goal, feed him 28-30 carries.

Colts Beat Dolphins as Daniel Jones Posts Worst QBR This Season
Photo: sports.yahoo.com

Steichen’s play-calling leaned on 11 personnel (one back, one tight end, three receivers) for roughly 59 percent of offensive snaps, per Next Gen Stats — a heavy figure for a receiving corps gutted by the departures of Josh Downs and Keenan Allen. The Rams, by contrast, shifted to heavy sets and motion when their wideouts went down.

Indianapolis travels to Houston on Thursday night. Jones will start. The offensive identity — run-heavy, Warren-centric, creative — remains a projection, not a reality.