Columbia Calls Demand to Fire Chiefs in Firefighter Death Suit Egregious

City officials broke their silence Monday, calling settlement demands “egregious” after the Irmo Fire District offered to drop its lawsuit if Columbia Fire Chief Aubrey Jenkins and Deputy Chief Anthony Holloway lose their jobs, wistv.com reported.

The wrongful death suit stems from the May 2023 fire at Tropical Ridge Apartments that killed Irmo firefighter James Muller, 25. His widow, Emma Muller, filed the action nearly two years later alleging that deck guns and master streams deployed by the Columbia-Richland Fire Department caused a roof collapse while her husband was still inside.

Irmo Fire Seeks Columbia Fire Chief’s Firing, Apologies in Firefighter Death Lawsuit — WACH FOX

The Irmo Fire District’s settlement terms, delivered Monday, require Jenkins and Holloway to be terminated immediately, according to wistv.com. The district also demands reimbursement of roughly $40,296 in legal fees within 30 days, written apologies from both chiefs published in The State and The Post and Courier, and dismissal of all claims against the Irmo Fire District.

“We are in complete disagreement with the allegations made by the other lawyers in this litigation and look forward to representing the men and women of the Columbia Fire Department before a neutral and detached jury,” city officials said in a social media post.

The city said it does not comment on pending litigation but called the demand for two longtime public servants to leave their jobs “egregious.” Jenkins must apologize for alleging that the Irmo Fire District or its employees gave false statements to investigating agencies. Holloway must apologize for alleging that Sloane Valentino wrote the NIOSH report.

Jenkins began his career with the department in 1979 and rose through every rank before becoming fire chief on July 20, 2011, the first African American appointed to the post. He later became the first African American elected president of the South Carolina State Association of Fire Chiefs. Under his leadership the department achieved a Class 1 ISO rating, the highest fire protection classification, a milestone no previous chief had reached.

A hearing in the case is scheduled for Dec. 14 in Richland County. The Irmo Fire Department declined to comment on the pending litigation when contacted by wistv.com.

Irmo Fire District settlement offer calls for firing of Columbia-Richland fire chief — News 19 WLTX