Columbus Woman Sentenced to 29 Years to Life for Murder of 5-Year-Old Foster Son Darnell Taylor

Franklin County Common Pleas Judge Mark Serrott sentenced Pammy Maye, 51, to 29 years to life in prison Thursday for the aggravated murder of five-year-old Darnell Taylor, Cleveland 19 News reported.

A jury found Maye guilty on all counts Nov. 10 after a two-day trial, rejecting a defense of not guilty by reason of insanity, according to WYSU and CW Columbus. Maye was the child’s legal guardian; she and her husband had been granted custody in May 2023.

Columbus woman Pammy Maye sentenced to 29 years to life in prison for the murder of a 5-year-old boy — WKYC Channel 3

The crime and the investigation

Columbus police issued an AMBER Alert for Taylor after Maye’s husband called 911 just after 3 a.m. on Feb. 14, 2024, saying his wife had woken him and told him she had harmed the child, Cleveland 19 News reported. Maye’s abandoned Jeep Cherokee was found at Parkview Estates on Memphis Avenue in the Cleveland suburb of Brooklyn at 5:50 a.m. that same day.

Brooklyn police arrested Maye around 9:30 p.m. on Feb. 15 after a business owner reported a woman walking suspiciously around a building, Cleveland 19 News reported. During an interview, she told officers where to find Taylor’s body. Just after 1 a.m. on Feb. 16, Columbus officers recovered the body from a storm drain, Cleveland 19 News and Fox 19 reported.

A woman sits at a table in a courtroom. A man dressed in a suit sits nearby
Photo: wysu.org

Jury Rejected Insanity Defense at Trial

At the center of the trial was whether Maye was legally insane when she killed the boy, WYSU reported. Defense attorney Sam Shamansky told reporters after the verdict that the justice system needs to be reformed to help people like Maye who are mentally ill but not insane, WYSU reported.

Prosecutors and the defense both agreed Maye suffered from mental illness and committed the crime, but the jury agreed with prosecutors that she knew what she did was wrong, CW Columbus reported.

“It doesn’t take away from the very emotional and psychological turmoil that Pammy Maye suffers, every day of her life and will take to her grave regrettably.”

The trial had been delayed after Maye was found unfit to stand trial; once her competency was restored, she was offered a plea deal, which she rejected, CW Columbus reported.

Columbus woman has courtroom outburst while sentenced for killing 5-year-old boy — 19 News

Columbus Police Commander Dave Hughes, the first CPD investigator to interview Maye after her arrest, visited Taylor’s gravesite with other officers shortly before the verdict was read, leaving a baby Yoda at the headstone, CW Columbus reported.

“Today seeing the headstone and seeing the jury come back, restored my faith in humanity and the system.”

Columbus, founded in 1812 at the confluence of the Scioto and Olentangy rivers, was planned as the state capital for its central location and became Ohio’s seat of government in 1816. It grew into the state’s largest city by both area and population by the early 1990s and serves as the county seat of Franklin County, where the trial was held.

Hughes added that the outcome means Maye will not be able to hurt anyone else, CW Columbus reported. Shamansky called the case a tragedy and said the lack of a diminished-capacity option in Ohio law is a systemic problem, CW Columbus reported.

Columbus Woman Sentenced to 29 Years to Life for Murder of 5-Year-Old Foster Son Darnell Taylor
Photo: fox19.com