A commentary published by VTDigger argues the federal tax code penalizes labor while shielding wealth, proposing a system that taxes every dollar of income at the same progressive rates regardless of source.
In Vermont, personal income tax provides more than half of general fund revenue.
The asymmetry is stark. SpaceX advertised salaries of $90,000 to $160,000 for an executive assistant, Neuman notes, every paycheck taxable as income. Meanwhile, equity holders like Elon Musk can finance lifestyles through loans backed by shares — “buy, borrow, die,” as estate planners call it — accessing cash without selling assets or triggering capital gains taxes.
A check, on its own, gives a person none of that.”
Justin Neuman, professor of literary studies, Eugene Lang College

Neuman’s “humanist tax code” would eliminate federal income tax on the first $64,000 of income from any source for everyone. Above that threshold, wages, capital gains, dividends, and business income would face the same progressive schedule, without a preferential rate for capital gains. Gains would be taxed upon realization, mirroring the Tax Reform Act of 1986 signed by President Ronald Reagan, which taxed gains and wages at a top rate of 28 percent.
Inheritances would be treated as income to recipients above a large lifetime exemption. Neuman cites an estimate that inherited income is currently taxed at less than one-seventh the average rate on income from work. Social Security, Medicare, and their supporting payroll taxes would remain untouched, as would the safety net.
The math, Neuman argues, works. With a taxable base around $10 trillion, an effective rate of roughly one-third would replace the $3.2 trillion federal income taxes raise today. Under one modeled schedule, a carpenter or first-year Vermont teacher earning $50,000 would owe zero federal income tax instead of roughly $4,000.
A school principal at $100,000 would owe about $5,000, less than half the current roughly $13,000. A hedge fund manager earning $5 million would owe more than $2 million, nearly double the likely current burden.
The proposal arrives as automation accelerates. Neuman points to Anthropic and Nvidia generating more than $5 million in revenue per employee as evidence that companies are wagering on replacement — producing more with fewer workers. If returns grow while labor’s share shrinks, a code that taxes labor most heavily becomes unsustainable.
The commentary does not address political feasibility or transition costs.
Related reading
- NYC Braces for Storm Disrupting Thanksgiving Travel: 1-3 Inches of Rain, Gusty Winds Expected Sunday Evening
- Ophir Elementary ASL Interpreter Competes for Miss Rodeo America Crown
- Real Rates, Not Inflation Bets, Drove the 10-Year Yield to a 2002 High (daybreakwire.com)
- UK property market momentum slows as rising mortgage rates hit buyers (newsarchyuk.com)