Connecticut Female Judges Share Career Paths, Mentorship Advice at Quinnipiac University

“It was my colleagues in the Attorney General’s office who had said, ‘you really should think about becoming a judge,'” Nina Elgo told The Quinnipiac Chronicle.

Four female Connecticut judges gathered at Quinnipiac University’s North Haven Campus to share their career paths with aspiring legal professionals. The Nov. 18 event inside the Brooke A. Goff Courtroom drew students and lawyers alike.

Moderated by Lt. Governor Susan Bysiewicz, the panel was hosted jointly by the Governor’s Council on Women and Girls Leadership Subcommittee and the Connecticut Bar Association Women in the Law Section.

Titled “Women in the Judiciary,” the discussion featured Judge Nina Elgo of the Connecticut Appellate Court, Ndidi Moses of the Connecticut Superior Court, Sarala Nagala of the US District Court for the District of Connecticut, and Justice Melanie Cradle of the Connecticut Supreme Court.

Encouragement from peers marked the starting point for each panelist. Elgo said that she had never originally considered the bench until her colleagues suggested it.

Mentorship also shaped their trajectories, often appearing in unexpected places. Moses shared how she met her first mentor while running on a treadmill at 6 a.m.

“My first mentor in the legal profession I met on the treadmill at 6 a.m. running,” Moses told The Quinnipiac Chronicle.

“He went on to become governor’s counsel when I was in law school, and every single opportunity he could possibly find, he would send me an email about. And he didn’t know me. All he knew was I liked to run…But just through our conversations in the morning, he took an interest in my career.”

For Nagala, mentors provided vital pushes when self-doubt surfaced. “They have put me in positions to think of me for opportunities and to push me in directions that I wasn’t even sure I or confident I could pursue,” Nagala told The Quinnipiac Chronicle.

Patience and Balance in Court

While the legal field demands sharp technical skills, the panelists emphasized patience as an unexpected necessity. Cradle pointed out the need to listen without letting personal biases interfere with judgment.

Elgo added that humility and the willingness to admit mistakes are equally critical. Managing high-stakes decisions requires separating personal reactions from the case at hand.

Moses, who presides over family court, described the heavy toll of rulings where no party leaves completely satisfied. “It is a court where no one truly wins,” Moses told The Quinnipiac Chronicle.

“The fact that they’re even there says that something dramatic has happened. And every single case I’ve ever had is a case that I spend a lot of time worried that I’m making the wrong decision.”

Cradle advised explaining judicial decisions in plain language to help participants understand the reasoning behind difficult outcomes. Balancing a demanding career with family life presented ongoing struggles for the speakers, with Cradle noting the constant feeling of being pulled in multiple directions.

“I always felt like I was sacrificing something, either my professional life or my home life,” Cradle told The Quinnipiac Chronicle. “I wanted to be there for my kids. Nothing I did was good enough. You feel like you’re pulled in all these directions.”

Audience Q&a and Overcoming Prejudice

The event concluded with an audience question-and-answer session involving high school, college, and law students alongside practicing attorneys. Layla Char, a high school sophomore, asked the panel about handling prejudice and obstacles encountered as women in the judiciary.

Bysiewicz, born in 1961 in New Haven and raised on a farm in Middletown, earned degrees from Yale University and Duke University School of Law.

She served three terms in the Connecticut House of Representatives beginning in 1992 before winning election as Secretary of the State in 1998, a post she held until 2011. During that tenure she created the state’s first electronic voter registration system and the CONCORD business search database. She became lieutenant governor in 2019.

Elgo advised keeping focus on the work rather than external barriers. “You just let it go and you do the best you can and laugh it off and understand this is not about me,” Elgo told The Quinnipiac Chronicle.