COP31 Climate Talks Enter Overtime as Nations Face Showdown Over Fossil Fuel Language

UN climate talks in Antalya, Turkey, collapsed into overtime on Saturday as a coalition of roughly 130 nations prepared to force a public showdown with Saudi Arabia over the removal of fossil fuel language from the draft Cop31 agreement.

The negotiations, co-chaired by Australia and Turkey, blew past their Friday deadline after a revised text published Thursday stripped out the “transition away from fossil fuels” pledge secured at Cop28 in Dubai. The excision triggered a dramatic march to the presidency office on Saturday by European, African, Pacific, and least-developed nations demanding its reinstatement, while developing countries simultaneously denounced the deletion of a $120 billion adaptation finance target.

The Two-Word Trap

The crisis centers on two words — “fossil fuels” — that have haunted the UN process since Dubai. The first draft of the Cop31 “cover decision,” released Monday, explicitly called for an “immediate transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems.” By Thursday, after intense pressure from the Saudi-led Arab bloc, all mention of coal, oil, and gas had vanished.

“This echoes what happened last year at Cop30 where references to fossil fuels were stripped from the final agreement.” The pattern suggests a systemic stall: the 2023 Dubai pledge has been neither repeated nor built upon in two subsequent summits.

“We’re talking about the root cause of all this. [Without it] we are wasting our time here.”

said Maina Talia, climate minister for Tuvalu, telling The Irish Times the reference is a “red line” for the low-lying Pacific nation.

COP31 Climate Talks Enter Overtime as Nations Face Showdown Over Fossil Fuel Language
Photo: RTÉ

Panama’s environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, struck a similar tone, telling reporters, “It is not acceptable to have a Cop or a cover decision that does not even mention fossil fuels and we simply will not put up with it.” Panama has gone further, demanding a cap on global oil production at current levels.

Saudi Arabia Pushes Strongly Endorse Carbon Capture

While the progressive coalition pushes for a phase-out, Saudi Arabia is pushing in. Riyadh wants the final text to strongly endorse Carbon Capture Utilisation and Storage (CCUS), framing it as a tool to limit 1.5°C overshoot. Neil Grant, a senior mitigation expert at Climate Analytics, called the technology a “Trojan horse for fossil fuel interests” in comments to The Guardian.

France’s ecological transition minister, Monique Barbut, backed that assessment, telling reporters the CCUS references serve as “a licence for other countries to keep burning oil and gas.” The Arab bloc argues each nation should decide its own energy mix, a position RTÉ said remained immovable as of Saturday night.

The OPEC secretary general, Haitham Al Ghais, met with Russia’s climate envoy, Ruslan Edelgeriev, in Antalya on Friday, a coordination signal posted on X and noted by The Journal.

COP31 Climate Talks Enter Overtime as Nations Face Showdown Over Fossil Fuel Language
Photo: CNN

Electrification Without Decarbonization

With the fossil fuel language gone, the Turkish presidency has pivoted to a “35 by 35” target: deriving 35% of global energy from electricity by 2035, up from 23% today. The target remains in the draft, but critics say it is hollow without a renewable mandate.

“Electrification without a clear commitment to the transition away from fossil fuels sends an incomplete signal.”

said Gustavo Pinheiro of the think tank E3G. Chiara Martinelli of Climate Action Network Europe warned that uncoupled electrification “gives the fossil fuel industry cover to carry on as usual, raking in profits while ordinary people are hit by rising energy bills.”

Developing Nations Question Promised Financial Support

Running parallel to the energy fight is a deepening trust deficit over money. Developing nations say wealthy countries spent two weeks “finding reasons not to deliver the [financial] support they promised,” Mohamed Adow of Power Shift Africa told The Irish Times. The removal of the $120 billion (€109.19 billion) adaptation target from the draft inflamed the G77 and China bloc, The Journal reported.

“You can’t ask developing countries to transform their economies while they’re drowning in disasters and debt,” said Harjeet Singh, global convener of the Fill the Fund campaign, speaking to The Irish Times. “Whatever deal emerges in Antalya, the world should know why this Cop failed. It wasn’t a lack of solutions, it was a lack of money and a lack of will from those who caused this crisis.”

The EU disputes the characterization. A senior official told The Guardian the bloc and its members provided €32.3 billion from public sources and mobilized €9.3 billion in private finance in 2025. “We’re doing by far the most,” the official said. Yet RTÉ reported the EU has signaled flexibility on making finance more accessible, a key demand from Jordan.

A Fractured Presidency

This is the first Cop with a dual presidency, a compromise forged after Australia and Turkey both bid to host. Claudio Angelo of Observatorio do Clima told The Irish Times the arrangement has backfired: “It goes to show how a weak presidency, split between two countries with little tradition in climate diplomacy, can be detrimental to a process already victimised by geopolitics.”

Australia’s Chris Bowen, chairing the negotiations, insisted Thursday a deal was still possible. “What we’re doing is finding the most ambitious outcome that consensus will allow,” he said. By Sunday morning, Turkish Environment Minister Murat Kurum told delegates, “We are closer than ever to agreement on the remaining issues,” the BBC reported.

A man in a blue suit sitting down in front of a placard that says 'COP President' is surrounded by seven people in suits
Photo: BBC

Few in the hall believed him. Andreas Sieber of 350.org called it “the worst Cop ever,” telling CNN the presidencies were guilty of “an outrageous and utterly embarrassing lack of leadership.”

Coalition Weighs Forcing Open Plenary

With consensus rules paralyzing the process, the “progressive coalition” is weighing a high-risk maneuver: forcing an open plenary where Saudi Arabia would be compelled to isolate itself publicly by vetoing language supported by the vast majority.

Bill Hare of Climate Analytics told The Irish Times the kingdom would likely fold rather than stand alone. The Guardian reported China and India, while not part of the 130-nation coalition, are unlikely to block a deal.

COP31 Climate Summit – Fight Over Fossil Fuels Leaves Global Climate Talks in Deadlock — CNN-News18

EU Climate Commissioner Wopke Hoekstra laid down the marker Saturday: “Clearly there’s no compromise yet. It’s better to have no deal than to have a bad deal,” he told reporters, per RTÉ. Ireland’s Darragh O’Brien echoed the line, confirming the 130-country headcount to The Journal.

If the gambit fails, or if delegates flee before quorum is met, the summit could end with no cover decision — only the second time since 1995 — and reconvene next year, the BBC noted. The last Cop to finish on time was in Italy in 2003.

COP31 Climate Talks Enter Overtime as Nations Face Showdown Over Fossil Fuel Language
Photo: The Journal

Action Outside the Hall

While Antalya stalls, national capitals are moving. On November 17, Denmark, Portugal, Luxembourg, and Spain unveiled domestic fossil fuel phase-out roadmaps, joining a Brazil-led initiative, euronews reported. Finland already generates over 96% of its electricity from non-fossil sources.

“Roadmaps need to be more than just a reiteration of existing policies,” said Romain Ioualalen of Oil Change International. “We need to see rich countries accelerate their exit from fossil fuels to align with global climate goals.”

Cop31 pushes into overtime — Guardian Australia

Miatta Fahnbulleh, the UK’s energy minister, told The Irish Times: “We are working closely with partners to find a way through and secure an agreement that moves us forward. These are difficult negotiations, but discussions remain productive and there is a deal to be done.”

Delegates were rescheduling flights for Sunday night.