Dane County DA Rules Out Charges in Corey Ruiz Shooting by Madison Officer

Prosecutors ruled out criminal charges against a Madison police officer on Wednesday, Nov. 19, closing the door on a prosecution many activists demanded after the July shooting death of Corey Ruiz.

Dane County District Attorney Ismael Ozanne concluded that Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson acted reasonably when he fired, striking Ruiz twice, after Ruiz resisted arrest, produced a knife and was not subdued by two Taser deployments, WPR reported.

“A person does not have to like and [or] agree with the law, however I am sworn to apply the law to the facts at hand,” Ozanne wrote in his four-page decision letter released that afternoon.

Dane County DA Ismael Ozanne Brings No Charges in Corey Ruiz Case — On Site Public Media

The announcement reignited protests at the Williamson Street site where Ruiz, a 38-year-old Black man, was killed on July 22, though the demonstrations remained calmer than the weeks-long encampment the city forcibly cleared in August, according to WPR. Mayor Satya Rhodes-Conway called the decision “disheartening” and said the continued employment of the four officers involved makes it difficult for the community to trust the department, USA Today reported.

“There is nothing on that video or the videos that he showed us to justify this execution of Corey Ruiz,” civil rights attorney Ben Crump said at a news conference. Crump, who represents the family, said he is exploring other legal avenues, including a civil rights lawsuit.

The legal framework that shaped the decision

Wisconsin’s self-defense statute applies identically to police officers and private citizens: deadly force is permitted when a person reasonably fears imminent death or great bodily harm. Because Ruiz brandished a knife — classified as a dangerous weapon — and Tasers failed to stop him, the district attorney determined he could not disprove self-defense beyond a reasonable doubt, the standard required for a criminal conviction, WPR reported.

“It would have been, I think, reasonable under the law for an officer to conclude that they could use force,” John Gross, a Madison criminal defense attorney and former clinical professor who directed the Public Defender Project at UW Madison, told WPR. Gross said he expected the outcome from the start, given how the statute is written and applied.

The Department of Justice’s Division of Criminal Investigation turned over a nearly 1,800-page file to Ozanne, including a July 31 interview in which Baitinger-Peterson told investigators he feared Ruiz would stab him or the other officers clustered around the suspect, USA Today reported. Toxicology results included in the DA’s statement showed Ruiz had methamphetamine and THC in his system at the time of the encounter.

Policy review and civil exposure remain open

While criminal liability is off the table, the Madison Police Department will undergo an internal use-of-force review by an outside expert, WPR reported. Chief John Patterson said he has only taken a “quick look” at the evidence so far and a full internal review will likely not conclude until 2027, the Daily Cardinal reported. The four officers remain on paid leave.

Dane County DA Rules Out Charges in Corey Ruiz Shooting by Madison Officer
Photo: dailycardinal.com

A complaint seeking Baitinger-Peterson’s termination is pending before the Police and Fire Commission, the only body with authority to fire a Madison officer, WPR reported. In civil court, the family would face a lower “preponderance of the evidence” standard — 51 percent rather than proof beyond a reasonable doubt — though qualified immunity could shield the officer from personal liability in a federal civil rights suit, Gross told WPR.

“Just because the officer’s actions don’t rise to the level of a crime … does not mean that the officers’ actions were, you know, reasonable overall in terms of the policies and procedures that are in place,” Gross said.

A gap in civilian oversight

Interim Independent Police Monitor Rebecca Kemble was hired after the firing of former IPM Aeiramique Glass, who was fired due to an alleged misallocation of funds and an altercation with MPD regarding the Ruiz case, the Daily Cardinal reported. Devon Snyder, chair of the Police Civilian Oversight Board, said he is “deeply concerned” the case concluded without the “benefit” of a review by a sitting monitor.

“The absence of an IPM during this critical period represents a significant gap in our oversight framework,” Snyder said in a Nov. 19 statement.

Rhodes-Conway has urged MPD to work with the Common Council and the public to examine de-escalation policies, echoing a Milwaukee policy that mandates public release of video in officer-involved deaths, the Daily Cardinal reported. Patterson said he supports adopting a similar rule in Madison.

Ismael Ozanne, a lifelong Madison resident and West High School graduate, was appointed district attorney by Gov. Jim Doyle in 2010 after serving as deputy secretary of the Department of Corrections, where he oversaw daily operations of a $1.2 billion agency with 10,000 employees. He is the first African American to hold the office in Wisconsin history.

The Police and Fire Commission hearing on Baitinger-Peterson’s employment is scheduled for December.