Debbie Goodstein’s Play Runs at Theatre Row, Explores Jewish Family Divide Over Israel

A new off-Broadway play opening in Manhattan turns an Upper West Side engagement party into a pressure test for American Jewish identity, staging the fracture between a Holocaust-haunted generation and a campus activist questioning Israel’s right to exist.

Debbie Goodstein’s “The Blue Violinist Over West End Avenue” runs through December 5 at Theatre Row, and its central collision — a son bringing home an anti-Zionist girlfriend — arrives as real families face the same silence at Shabbat tables nationwide, The Times of Israel reported. The production opened late last month.

Goodstein began writing before the October 7, 2023, attacks, driven by what her children described on campus: Jewish students turning against Israel while pro-Israel peers stayed quiet. At her son’s Brown University graduation, she brought pro-Israel signs; other parents whispered support but refused to hold them. “I think that’s where we are right now. I think people are afraid to defend Israel,” Goodstein told The Times of Israel.

The cast of "The Blue Violinist Over West End Avenue." Photo: Jeremy Daniel
Photo: algemeiner.com

The play unfolds in two acts straddling October 7. Act one captures the weekend before the invasion; act two stretches a month into the war. The enigmatic blue violinist — a nod to Marc Chagall’s post-immigration painting — floats above the Stein family as a symbol of what Goodstein calls “80 years of, basically, good fortune in this country,” now shadowed by the precariousness Tevye’s fiddler once embodied in the shtetl.

Goodstein’s mother survived the Holocaust hidden in an attic for two years; her mother-in-law survived Auschwitz. Goodstein told The Algemeiner her mother died in April at the age of 88, and their history anchors the matriarch Dina’s warning to the audience: “Acceptance gets you a seat at the table. But assimilation, that changes the menu.”

The line, delivered by Tony-nominated Barbara Walsh, crystallizes the play’s argument that safety and erasure are not the same bargain.

To write Jenna, the anti-Zionist girlfriend, Goodstein spent hours on the phone with a Jewish Brown student who spoke at graduation wearing a keffiyeh and had spent time in the West Bank. “She’s lovely. We had great conversations,” Goodstein told The Times of Israel.

“I don’t know if we resolved anything, but there was more of a connection and a sense of understanding. Digging in our heels is not going to do anyone any good.”

Theatre Row, the Off Broadway district on 42nd Street where the play runs, was created in 1977 to convert adult entertainment venues into theatres between Ninth and Tenth Avenues; its grand opening was held on May 13, 1978, with Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis serving as a director of the development corporation. The Theatre Row Building was redesigned in 1999 and again reopened after renovations on June 17, 2019.

“Every member of the Stein family believes they’re acting out of conviction. They all care deeply about justice, identity, and the future, but they don’t agree on what those things mean. And sometimes the people we love most are the people who can hurt us most and most deeply. I don’t think love means we have to agree. And I don’t think family means we have to renounce our convictions.”

Debbie Goodstein, playwright, to The Algemeiner

Goodstein describes the play as “unapologetically Jewish,” complete with Shabbat prayers on stage. Jewish audiences have responded with standing ovations, she said, while non-Jewish viewers connect through the universal architecture of familial rupture.

The question hanging over the final curtain is not policy but proximity: “How do we stay connected to family and stay connected to Israel, which I think is very important, and part of the people who we are?”