Democrats Break 30-year Republican Grip on Texas statewide offices

Democrats Break 30-year Republican Grip on Texas statewide offices

by

Texas Republicans went into Tuesday night braced for bad numbers. What they got instead was a historic rout that ended the party’s three-decade hold on statewide office, with Democrats picking up race after race in a state long treated as the backbone of the national GOP, The Dallas Morning News reported.

The scale of the defeat stunned even the winners. James Talarico, a Presbyterian seminarian, defeated scandal-plagued Attorney General Ken Paxton for a U.S. Senate seat. Gina Hinojosa, a former school board president, unseated Gov. Greg Abbott to become the state’s first Latina governor. Vikki Goodwin topped Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, Jon Rosenthal beat Bo French, and Sarah Eckhardt defeated Comptroller Don Huffines. Early voting among traditional Republican primary voters had lagged Democrats, with record turnout in urban centers — warnings that, as it turned out, understated the collapse.

“The blue wave finally arrived in Texas,” said Ross Hunt, a Republican pollster in Dallas. “There’s going to be a lot of hand-wringing, some neck-wringing, and soul searching for Republicans.”

A Blame Game Erupts From Dallas to Austin

Within hours, Republicans turned on one another. Huffines, speaking at his election night party, pointed directly at the party’s top two leaders. “It’s going to be almost impossible to win this state back,” he said. “I blame it on our leadership. I blame this on Greg Abbott. I blame it on Dan Patrick.” The Houston Chronicle reported that Huffines criticized both men for seeking fourth terms and argued that campaigning on lowering property taxes only reminded voters the promise had gone unfulfilled for 12 years. “People are tired of the Republicans in office,” he said, also blaming what he called the party’s “mushy middle people.”

President Donald Trump, who had endorsed Abbott’s reelection, added his own insult on Truth Social, accusing the governor of becoming a “RINO” — Republican in name only — in the final six months of the campaign. “He went back to his original formula, and it wasn’t pretty!” Trump wrote.

“We deserve the butt whipping we got,” said Jerry Patterson, a former state senator and Texas land commissioner from 2002 to 2015. “Texas’ leaders allowed Trump to hijack the state.”

What Drove Voters Away

Mark Jones, a political science professor at Rice University who studies Texas politics, said the results delivered a clear rebuke to Trump, whose approval rating had sunk to 32% ahead of the midterms. Unlike previous presidents with low approval ratings, Trump refused to distance himself from fellow Republicans as Election Day neared. Across Texas, Jones said, anger over data centers and public school vouchers fueled the perception that Republicans had stopped caring about the average Texan.

“You can talk about a blue wave,” Jones said, “but this was a blue tsunami.”

Some conservative influencers offered a different explanation, blaming Democratic wins on immigration and the influx of Muslim and Indian immigrants — each roughly 1% to 2% of the state’s population. “This is national,” commentator Sara Gonzales wrote. “Mass migration. Birthright citizenship. Communists in our institutions.”

The All-In Podcast's

Voters themselves described a quieter exhaustion. Bruce Goff, a 49-year-old mechanical engineer and longtime Republican in Arlington, said he now considers himself an independent and voted for Talarico and Hinojosa. He cited dissatisfaction with the party’s leadership and handling of the economy, noting that gasoline and grocery prices had worsened under the Trump administration. He also watched hundreds of Republican ads that attacked opponents but never said what the candidates would actually do. “It’s time for change,” Goff said. “It’s time to balance the system.”

Crossing the Aisle for the First Time

The coalition that flipped Texas crossed party lines. John Huffman, the former Republican mayor of Southlake and a self-described Christian conservative, said Democrats, independents and Republicans alike rejected Trump and concluded the party had not done enough for their families. Huffman, who lost a bitter primary last year to conservative activist Leigh Wambsganss — who in turn lost Tuesday to Democrat Taylor Rehmet — said he could not vote for Paxton or French.

Democrats Break 30-year Republican Grip on Texas statewide offices
Photo: chron.com

John Huffman said a party cannot keep nominating just anyone and expect to win riding on 30 years of dominance. Texans still want right-of-center leadership, but it will come from men and women of strong character, highly competent and focused on their constituents’ problems and their lives.

Huffman said Republicans can win again, and “this time in the wilderness can be temporary, but only if we learn the right lessons.”

What a Blue Texas Means Nationally

The shockwaves extend well beyond Austin. Texas has served for years as a workshop for conservative policies, including abortion bans and Bible readings in public schools, and its electoral votes have been central to Republican presidential math. Some acknowledged that electing Republican presidents would be far harder in a blue — or even purple — state.

U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz sounded the alarm during an election night livestream on The All-In Podcast, predicting that Democratic gains in Congress would bring investigations into Trump, his family and Cabinet members. “I think we will also see two years of relentless impeachment,” Cruz said. “I believe the House will impeach Donald Trump if they have the House. They may impeach him multiple times.” He also cautioned that Senate Democrats could block judicial confirmations, potentially leaving a Supreme Court vacancy unfilled for two years.

For now, the soul searching is just beginning. Hunt, the GOP pollster who has worked in Texas politics since 2008, said the party must unite and refocus on the fundamentals of governing, because voters believe Republicans have grown too proud to listen. “They think the Republican party has lost its way,” he said. “This is not a defeat that dictates the destiny of Texas Republicans. It’s a much-needed corrective.”

Whether that correction happens quickly remains the open question Patterson posed when he said the party needs a “come-to-Jesus meeting” — and wondered aloud who would even convene it.

More on Texas Republicans

Democrats win top offices statewide, but Republicans still hold the line in the Texas Senate
Democrats sweep statewide offices in a seismic Election Day, reshaping the politics of Texas
WATCH: How Trump and Republicans reacted to midterm losses

More on this

Read next