A Denver homebuilder specializing in entry-level housing took its constitutional challenge to the city’s affordable housing mandates before the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Monday, arguing the requirements amount to an uncompensated taking of private property.
The case, brought by redT Homes LLC and argued by the Pacific Legal Foundation, targets Denver’s affordable housing program, which requires developers to either sell a portion of new units at below-market rates or pay a per-square-foot “linkage fee” to support the city’s affordable housing fund.
“It disgusts me that we’re passing (city charges) on to buyers while we give handouts to others,” Adams told the Gazette following oral arguments. His company, which began building in 2011 when entry-level prices sat in the high $300,000s, now delivers homes in the $400,000s to $700,000s.
The appeal follows a March dismissal by U.S. District Judge Philip Brimmer. A three-judge panel — Joel Carson, Richard Federico, and Harris Hartz — pressed both sides on whether the mandate functions as an unconstitutional condition on land-use permits.
The math on a fourplex
For redT, which specializes in quadruplexes, that means surrendering 25% of a project’s inventory — far above the nominal 10% target.
On a recent four-unit townhome project in the Rosedale neighborhood, redT paid $48,000 in linkage fees — $12,000 per door — after initial price projections in the $900,000s settled around $809,000. Two upcoming projects illustrate the variance: a four-unit single-family development faces $25,000 in fees, while another, for two duplexes, would be subject to $45,000, according to figures cited in the foundation’s statement and Courthouse News coverage.
“From a practical perspective, nobody building under 10 units will choose to do mandated affordable housing,” said David Deerson, lead attorney for Pacific Legal Foundation. “It’s like a cudgel used to force people into paying the fees.”
Supreme Court precedent and the “bundle of sticks”
The legal framework rests on the Supreme Court’s 1987 and 1994 decisions, which established that permit conditions for new construction must be proportional and directly related to its impact. Deerson argued Denver’s scheme fails both tests by burdening builders for a housing shortage they did not create.
A 2023 Supreme Court decision overturning a California ruling on similar grounds served as a warning that Denver’s policies would be subject to the earlier U.S. Supreme Court cases.
During Monday’s argument, Judge Federico invoked the “bundle of sticks” metaphor for property rights, asking whether restricting the right to dispose of a unit at market value constitutes a taking.
Judge Hartz, a George W. Bush appointee, pressed the city further: “Here there’s a restriction that runs with the land. That’s a taking. You can defend this with your analysis, you can say it’s necessary and justified, but to say it’s not a taking, I don’t understand how you can do that.”
City attorney Adam Hernandez defended the ordinance, characterizing it as a restrictive covenant that does not amount to a government taking.
Who bears the cost?
Adams said that 90% or more of what his company has built over time has been affordably priced. At a 40-unit Berkeley development near West 38th Avenue and Perry Street, redT is including two income-restricted units priced in the low $300,000s — but buyers of those units face capped appreciation, limiting their equity gains when the market rebounds.
“It is a disingenuous handout. In the current market, where typical homes are depreciating, those owners may actually come out ahead, but when typical appreciation returns, they will be held back from benefiting.”
The Pacific Legal Foundation argues the ordinance creates a paradox: the builders most actively supplying attainable housing — LEED-certified, small-scale infill — face the steepest relative burden, while larger developers can absorb the 10% set-aside across hundreds of units.
Court ruling timeline unclear; city silent on appeal
The 10th Circuit gave no timeline for its ruling. Denver’s City Attorney’s office did not respond to requests for comment on the appeal.