Victor Moses wants the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to reinstate his federal civil-rights claims against the Denver Police Department and a dozen paramedics after a January 2023 training exercise cost him both legs below the knee, Courthouse News Service reported Tuesday.
The panel — Judges Veronica Rossman, Scott Matheson and Timothy Tymkovich — heard oral argument Tuesday on whether a recruit who disclosed sickle cell trait, passed out during a mandatory “fight day” drill, and was cleared to continue by on-site medics can pursue Fourth Amendment and substantive-due-process claims in federal court, or whether the case belongs exclusively in the workers-compensation system as the city argues.
“Denver is asking this court to find police recruits have fewer rights than regular citizens and even suspected criminals,” attorney David Kilmer told the three-judge panel.
The Training Exercise That Changed Everything
On January 6, 2023, Moses participated in “fight day,” a Denver Police Academy ritual that subjects recruits to a series of simulated violent assaults — being attacked, tackled and knocked to the ground — meant to replicate street encounters, Courthouse News Service reported. Moses had disclosed his sickle cell trait, a condition that raises the risk of exertional rhabdomyolysis and sudden collapse under extreme physical stress.
During the drill Moses grew fatigued and lost consciousness. Instructors urged him to keep going and paramedics cleared him to continue, his complaint alleges. The aftermath was catastrophic: four months hospitalized, multiple surgeries, dialysis, a drug-resistant infection, and bilateral below-knee amputations.

Judge Dismissed Federal Constitutional Claims
U.S. District Judge Gordon Gallagher dismissed two federal claims in 2025 — excessive force under the Fourth Amendment and conscience-shocking conduct under the Fourteenth — and remanded the remaining state-law claims to state court, Courthouse News Service reported.
Gallagher treated the episode as a workplace injury governed by Colorado’s exclusive-remedy provisions, drawing inferences in Denver’s favor rather than accepting Moses’s version of facts as true at the motion-to-dismiss stage, Kilmer argued on appeal.
Consent, Seizure, and the ‘Punch-Drunk Boxer’ Analogy
The argument Tuesday centered on whether Moses could legally consent to continue after he passed out. Judge Rossman, a Biden appointee, pressed Kilmer: “I’m having trouble understanding how he lost the legal ability to consent, because he said he wanted to continue.”
Kilmer countered that consciousness is a prerequisite for consent. “Consent is eviscerated at the time that he was knocked out,” he said, likening Moses to a punch-drunk boxer or a concussed football player who says “put me back in” but lacks capacity to decide.

Kilmer urged the panel to view the recruit’s inability to leave the drill as an unconstitutional seizure. Judge Matheson, an Obama appointee, tested the city’s limiting principle: “How far does it have to go for someone to be seized?”
City Frames the Case as Training, Not Restraint
Denver attorney Kristin Arthur insisted the officers’ intent was instructional, not custodial. “Officers here used force with the intent to train, not with the intent to restrain,” she told the panel. She acknowledged the injury was tragic but argued it does not “alter constitutional standards.”
When Judge Matheson pushed for an example of training conduct that would cross the constitutional line, Arthur declined to draw one, suggesting instead that “really bad training” might support a state tort claim but not a federal civil-rights action.
Paramedics Argue Negligence, Not Deliberate Indifference
Representing the paramedics, attorney Todd Drake of Hershey Decker in Lone Tree drew a sharp line between a negligent medical decision and a constitutional violation. “Deliberate indifference is ‘I have chosen not to provide care.’ Instead, they made the decision to render care,” Drake said. “That is not deliberate indifference, that is negligence.”
Why the Appeal Matters Beyond Denver
The outcome will shape how police academies across the 10th Circuit balance paramilitary conditioning against recruits’ constitutional protections.
The Panel Left Room for Fourth Amendment Standards
The panel gave no timetable for a decision.
“If this conduct was indeed conscience-shocking then that is something that would go to the Fourth Amendment,” Arthur conceded during argument, leaving the door ajar for the panel to define a standard that has so far eluded the circuit.