A Dubai court has ruled that employers in the financial free zone can fire staff on notice without giving a reason, even if the termination costs the employee a six-figure bonus.
The DIFC Court of First Instance dismissed a claim for roughly CHF 300,000 in discretionary bonus pay, confirming that an unqualified contractual right to terminate on notice does not carry an implied duty of good faith. The judgment, Paget v Padresa [2026] DIFC CFI 045, was reported by law firm Morgan Lewis.
The bonus that triggered the dispute
The employee, a relationship manager at executive director level, signed a contract on June 21, 2023. After probation, either side could end the employment with three months’ notice. The contract said that variable compensation was discretionary, created no entitlement to future payments, and was conditional on neither party having given notice before the payment date.
If notice had been served, any pending bonus instalments would be forfeited with no pro-rated entitlement. Those same terms appeared in the employer’s handbook and variable compensation guidebook.
On November 24, 2025, the employer gave three months’ notice, setting a termination date of February 23, 2026. The relevant bonus payment date fell after employment ended. The employee sued for the bonus, arguing the employer’s right to terminate should be subject to an implied obligation of good faith, requiring the court to examine the reasons for the dismissal.
Good faith argument rejected
H.E. Justice Mark Pelling held that the employer had an unqualified contractual right to terminate on three months’ notice. That right was consistent with Article 62 of DIFC Employment Law No. 2 of 2019, as amended, which expressly permits termination without cause subject to notice requirements.
“In my judgment, it is beyond argument that the Defendant was entitled to serve notice for any or no reason and thus the need for an investigation of whether or not there was a legitimate reason for terminating the contract is simply one that does not arise.”
H.E. Justice Pelling
The court relied on DIFC Court of Appeal authorities including Lutfi v DIFCA and Al Herz v DIFCA, which emphasise the primacy of express contractual termination provisions and the statutory framework. The employee’s attempt to import an implied good faith qualification under Article 57 of the DIFC Contract Law failed.
Because the termination was valid, the contractual bonus conditions were not met — notice had been given before the payment date and employment had ended. The court granted immediate judgment for the employer, dismissing the bonus claim without a full trial.
What this means for DIFC employers
The decision reinforces that an employee cannot ordinarily challenge a valid exercise of an unqualified termination right by arguing the employer lacked a legitimate reason or acted without good faith. Statutory protections against discrimination and victimisation remain, as do any additional contractual obligations.
The outcome turned on precise drafting: the contract, handbook and guidebook all aligned on bonus eligibility, payment dates, the effect of notice, and the absence of pro-rated entitlement. Employers should review employment contracts, bonus plans, incentive policies and handbooks to ensure provisions are consistent and do not inadvertently create conflicting entitlements.