Sacramento Council Approves Axon Surveillance Contract Over Public Opposition

Sacramento’s city council approved a $17.7 million, five-year agreement with Axon Enterprise on Tuesday, overriding hours of public opposition to consolidate six police and fire technology contracts into a single surveillance package.

The 6-1 vote, with Councilmembers Caity Maple and Rick Jennings absent, authorizes the purchase of body cameras, automated license plate readers, drones, interview-room recording software and a real-time video platform known as FUSUS, CapRadio reported. Councilmember Mai Vang cast the lone dissenting vote.

“Surveillance should never become a substitute for public safety,” Vang said. “Our responsibility as mayor and council is to protect public safety while also safeguarding the privacy and civil liberties of the people we serve.”

Kaplan’s amendments force Axon to the table

Councilmember Lisa Kaplan spearheaded a set of safety clauses. Her motion establishes the city as the sole owner of its data, imposes a 30-day termination clause and caps license-plate data retention. If Axon rejects any term, the contract returns to the council for another vote.

“We don’t have to accept a master contract just because it’s given to us,” Kaplan said. “It’s Axon or it’s Flock, and a lot of people are leaving Flock. But we can also ask Axon to comply with state law.”

Sacramento Council Approves Axon Surveillance Contract Over Public Opposition
Photo: yahoo.com

The amendments also require Axon to comply with California sanctuary laws, a direct response to advocates who say federal immigration agents are using license-plate data to track residents for detention. Volunteers monitoring the John Moss Federal Building have long suspected such access.

“I hear from our Sac PD they’re not accessing our system. Well, what system are they accessing to be able to know where people live?”

— Lisa Kaplan, Sacramento Councilmember

Staffing crisis frames the surveillance debate

Mayor Kevin McCarty and police officials argue the technology is a force multiplier for a department in crisis. In October, Sacramento Police Officers Association Dustin Smith told CapRadio the department has been understaffed for nearly a decade and is projected to drop to 600 officers in a city that should have more than 1,000.

McCarty pointed to a September homicide outside a Panera Bread where automated license plate readers helped apprehend a suspect within seven minutes. “We were able to solve crimes and keep our community safer,” he said.

Critics cite cost, mission creep and a class-action suit

Over 20 public commenters opposed the agreement. Resident Angelica Brown contrasted the $17.7 million price tag with cuts to social services. “You guys should be supporting organizations that help kids, help immigrants, help homelessness,” Brown said. “The budget cuts for that are just disheartening when guys are asking for over $17 million for people that don’t even feel protected.”

Opponents also highlighted a recent class-action lawsuit alleging Axon violated California’s license-plate reader privacy law. The contract includes 665 licenses for Auror’s Retail Crime Hub, software that builds profiles of suspected retail thieves — including physical descriptions, vehicles, associates and addresses — though police have not decided whether to deploy it.

“When cameras, locations and timestamps to vehicle data and video are connected, the government can reconstruct a person’s movements and patterns of life in ways no individual officer ever could.”

— Jessica Versoza, community advocate

In a separate 7-1 vote, the council renewed the police department’s military-equipment use policy, authorizing continued use and potential purchase of drones, ammunition, chemical agents and other weapons. Proposed purchases total approximately $186,405 from existing funds. Vang again dissented. “Do we need to keep funding military equipment in the city of Sacramento? And my answer is no,” she said.

The Axon contract now moves to negotiation; if the company rejects Kaplan’s clauses, the deal returns to the council for a new vote.