District Court Denies Leave to Appeal Preliminary Injunction in Solar Bankruptcy Dispute

U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV has refused to let a Massachusetts property trust immediately challenge a bankruptcy court order freezing settlement proceeds in a solar-farm dispute, ruling the order is interlocutory and does not meet the strict standard for early appeal.

The decision, issued Thursday in Boston, shuts down an attempt by Winthrop Street Property Trust to overturn a preliminary injunction that bars it from spending money Winthrop Street-Morra Solar, LLC says belongs to the bankruptcy estate. Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly reported the ruling in In re Winthrop Street-Morra Solar, LLC, Civil Action No. 26-10994-FDS.

The trust had argued the bankruptcy judge erred in granting the injunction, but Saylor found the appeal fails all three prongs of the 28 U.S.C. § 1292(b) test: the order does not present a controlling question of law, the legal issues are not unsettled, and an immediate appeal would not materially advance the end of the litigation.

“Much is left to be done before the adversary proceeding is finally concluded below,” Saylor wrote, noting the bankruptcy court must still rule on a motion to remand the removed state-court case and determine whether a settlement was actually reached before the Chapter 11 filing.

The fight traces back to a November 2014 lease for 297 Winthrop Street in Rehoboth, where the debtor agreed to build and operate a solar farm. The trust sued in Bristol County Superior Court in October 2021, alleging lease violations; the debtor counterclaimed. The parties dispute whether they settled before the debtor filed for Chapter 11 on May 18, 2025.

After removing the state case to bankruptcy court in August 2025, the debtor moved for a preliminary injunction on November 7 to preserve the contested settlement proceeds. The bankruptcy judge granted that motion orally on February 5, 2026, and entered a written order four days later.

The trust filed its notice of appeal on February 23, seeking leave to appeal the interlocutory order directly to the district court.

Saylor emphasized that challenging the bankruptcy court’s weighing of the preliminary-injunction factors — likelihood of success, irreparable harm, balance of equities, and public interest — amounts to disputing fact-specific application of settled law, not a pure legal question.

“Challenging the Bankruptcy Court’s findings as to the preliminary injunction factors, as the trust does, involves application of the law to the facts,” the opinion says. “The first prong is therefore not satisfied.”

Nor is the second prong met, Saylor wrote, because the legal standards governing preliminary injunctions are well established. On the third prong, he found that even if the trust won on appeal, the adversary proceeding would continue: the bankruptcy court must still decide the remand motion and the underlying merits.

“Here, reversal would not terminate either of the parties’ involvement in the case, much less the adversary proceeding as a whole,” Saylor concluded.

The case returns to the bankruptcy court for further proceedings on the motion to remand and the core dispute over the settlement’s existence and the lease claims. No date for the next hearing has been set.