DOJ Appeals Ruling Barring Essayli From Cases

The Justice Department said in a filing late Tuesday it will challenge a court ruling on Bill Essayli, pressing a legal fight that could reach the Supreme Court this winter.

Essayli was sworn in April 2025 as the top federal prosecutor in Los Angeles. He was initially appointed as an interim U.S. attorney. After that 120-day appointment expired, the administration designated him first assistant U.S. attorney to keep him in charge on an acting basis.

On Monday, Judge J. Michael Seabright of the Federal District Court in Hawaii refused to stay an earlier ruling that disqualified Essayli from overseeing two pending criminal cases because he was serving unlawfully.

DOJ Appeals Ruling Barring Essayli From Cases
Photo: thereader.ai

The Justice Department said it would “seek emergency relief.”

Essayli is not alone. The Supreme Court is already weighing whether to intervene in parallel cases involving Sigal Chattah in Nevada and John A. Sarcone III in the Northern District of New York. Any decision in those cases would affect a range of prosecutors, including Essayli. Chattah was the Republican candidate for Nevada attorney general in 2022. Sarcone has pursued investigations of Letitia James, the New York State attorney general.

In a separate filing Tuesday in the Chattah case, government lawyers argued the lower court decision “risks chaos during future presidential transitions and casts a pall over roughly a dozen U.S. Attorney's Offices nationwide.” The Department of Justice had no immediate comment on Tuesday.

Permanent U.S. attorney appointments typically require approval either by the U.S. Senate or by federal judges in the affected district. The administration’s workaround — appointing allies as interim U.S. attorneys, then converting them to first assistants after 120 days — has faced legal tests across multiple districts.

One of the most unusual clashes came in Seattle, where federal judges appointed Roger Rogoff, only for him to be fired by the administration less than an hour after his appointment. Rogoff filed a lawsuit contesting his termination, was briefly reinstated, and was then removed again pending a stay. Charles Neil Floyd, a former immigration judge installed by the Trump administration, has been running the office on an acting basis.

Anne Joseph O’Connell, a professor at Stanford University Law School, said a resolution could come soon, noting that petitions were pending on the Supreme Court calendar “for the Justices to discuss in early December.” How the issue is resolved, she added, could decide whether future presidents can get around Senate confirmations for a variety of offices, not just prosecutors.

The Essayli appeal was filed in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.